this is my opinion from best to worst
Street Fighter = Best from the start and always has = 12
WTF where is king of fighters.... = 11
WTF where is guilty gear (ggx2 was the best so i'm basing it on that) = 10
Tekken (as much as i hate tekken and hate how unblanced it is, from the list you got it) = 9
Soul Calibur = 8 or 7 (Soul cal kinda sucks now, very unbalanced)
Super smash bros (lol has to be a joke but it is a fighting game so i give it) = 7 to 8
Virtual Fighter (sorry VF havent played you to much so i had to give it a lower score)= 6
Dragonball z (lol i like the dbz games, good fun but not the best) =5
naruto = (havent played naruto to much but from what i've played) = 4
Mortal kombat (lol cant decide which is worse DOA or MK, weeelll MK was alright on sega sooo) = 3
Dead or Alive = (was always terrible) = 2
smackdown (again another joke) = 1