How should VGChartz score its reviews?

[ramuji]

TWRoO said:

Make it as simple as possible, we don't want all the "this game got 1% more" stuff.

Exactly. The % system may be the "standard", but then you'd also be saddled with all the ridiculous baggage that comes along with it.

The EGSU system sounds fine. Actually, I was thinking of a simple 5 star system, which is easy enough to convert to "points" or % for those who feel they must. I don't like the ABCDF system because of the ambiguity about how it indicates an average score. However, if you do decide to stick with ABCDF, I would prefer the removal of plusses and minuses. A five-point scale is sufficient.

Honestly, a two-point scale (thumbs up/thumbs down) would rock.  :)

TWRoO said:

@Machina... why do they need to be compared to other review sites....

Agreed. Dare to be different/better!