Great choice, both are great.
I think REmake is a much better game though. Sure the controls take some time, but once you're used to it RE is a much deeper game, due to the insanely high difficulty. The puzzles are amazing, often stretched around big area's and you'll have to be very conservative with your ammo, or you will get into big trouble. Oh yeah: Make absolutely sure to play as Jill in your first playthrough.
Eternal Darkness is awesome as well, great story and the different character system is very unique. I only find RE much more rewarding. It was one of the few times I was actually proud I finished a game, lol.







