Torillian on 12 November 2008
Looking at it, I think that LBP has a decent shot. It was well reviewed by all the sites I know, and it's fairly innovative which a lot of reviewers really like. Whether or not it "deserves" it is a discussion for another time, but I think it has a decent chance of happening on a number of sites.
Other games with a shot based on what I've seen:
MGS4
GTAIV
GeoW2.
My own personal choice will probably go between Valkyria and Persona 4
...
