MGS4 quite simply the greatest game this gen no doubt!!

[ZenfoldorVGI]

Hmm, MGS4 certainly is great.

IMHO

However, there are a few games I feel are equal to or better than MGS4 this gen.

First and foremost, is Fallout 3. It's just magnificent, immerse, and as fun as MGS4, but about 10 times longer with more replay value. It's my favorite game this generation.

I think the Gears 2 campaign comes close or ties MGS4.

I'd say Braid was equally as engaging, but slightly worse.

Super Mario Galaxy and Bioshock are both slightly better, imo, GTAIV slightly worse.

RE4 Wii edition, considerably better.

CoD4 equal.

LBP slightly worse.

I guess it's like this:

1. Fallout 3
2. RE4 Wii edition
3. Bioshock
4. Super Mario Galaxy
5/6. MGS4/CoD4
7. Gears 2
8. Braid
9. LBP
10. Gears 1
11. World of Goo
12. GTAIV

Honerable mention to Elite Beat Agents.

I think there are a lot of games that people have and haven't played. Including myself. While we might assume our favorite game is the best of the generation, it may be possible that other games, which we haven't played yet, might be better, like Gears 2, SMG, or Fallout 3.

It's all opinion.