What an awful review. He keeps complaining about stuff mandatory in almost every JRPG to date.
I don't see anyone complaining about GoW2, Halo3, Resistance2, Killzone 2 offering nothing new to the table.
People keep complaining about casual games destroying the market, but it's FPSs that are doing actual damage. Whatever doesn't have explosions, blood, muscle and a reticule is doomed and not good.
My themeforest portfolio:







