By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I've got to reiterate the sentiments of both of these posters. Madden '08 Wii
feels like it could be so much better, but there are times when it just doesn't deliver.

I *love* most of the controls, but the catch control is awful. Additionally, I think
I've juked *once* in the 9 or 10 games I've played since having the game. Its
just not as good as it could be.

The other thing that really bothers me is that I loved the old playcalling system.
I don't like the "Pick your individual play" system - I would much rather do it the
old fashioned way, and be able to do individual on the fly substitutions (a la the circle button on the old PS2 version, so I can use Reggie Bush as a WR, or substitute him in for Deuce McAlister if I wanted him in for a specific play, but not for another).

One last little bug that drives me nuts: the blur bug when coming out of the "big-play close-up." I don't know if anyone else has experienced this... but its atrocious. It hurts to watch the game when this bug is in effect.

All in all... a 7.5 is about right. It lacks features that I want and isn't quite as useable as older versions. Why update? I could do my own roster update, in that case.