I have Fable II and LBP.
LBP has been a disappointment for me and I can't say that I like it. Haven't played much yet so that could change but don't like sack boys movements (his jumps, how he runs, the limited 3D) and there is no real challenge... It's beautiful though. Also, I'm not into the whole creativity thing... I'd give it a 6 for me.
Fable II is rubbing me the right way, beautiful, rich, etc... Haven't gone far either but am excited to go and play this! Would go with a 8.5 at the moment.
From your list, am really thinking of getting Dead Space, and I ahve Bioshock on 360 (bought back when it came out) and that was awesome, a 9 for me. Not too interested in the others (have Resistance 1 and Gears 1 but not big on their sequels).
Elaine: I will never understand people
Jerry: They're the worst.
