Banjo Kazooie Eurogamer Review: NO PLATFORMING

[ZenfoldorVGI]

triplebph said:
Ninja Gaiden 2 didn't meet expectations. It only had a Metacritic score of 81. The first ones on the original XBOX were over 90%, the PS3 remake of the originals on the still scored 7 points higher than Ninja Gaiden 2. For Ninja Gaiden 2 to meet expectations, it would have had to have scored over a 90 and had a higher metacritic score than Sigma and it did neither. Lost Odyssey was called a Final Fantasy Killer on several forums. Did it come anywhere near getting Final Fantasy review scores? No. It failed to meet expectations. Same with Tales of Vesperia. People predicting that it would be the greatest Tales game ever. It fell a few points short of that goal and still no Tales game has ever gotten above an 8.5 at IGN. Resistance 2 is meeting expectations better than any of those 360 games that we mentioned. It still has a higher score than the first game in its series.

Fable 2's score, like Lost Odyssey and Tales score, is also lower than most games in the Final Fantasy series

Gears 2 was supposed to be the greatest game of all time, yet its Game Ranking's score is lower than those of both Little Big Planet and Bioshock PS3. Since Banjo is a Rare game, I felt it had a chance of giving the 360 some footing in Others if it came in with Little Big Planet size review scores but early reviews indicate that it is not going to be able to do that.

Reviews don't matter. They certainly aren't indicative of quality at such a small level of distinction.

You have consistantly changed your argument to fit your "360 library sucks because of reviews" theory.

Quoting IGN, then changing to Gamerankings, then metacritic, each time one doesn't suit your Pro-Sony anti-360 arugment, you move the goalposts a little, and quote some other review source that does fit your argument.

The truth is, that way more negative things can be brought up about the PS3s library, this very year, than can about the Xbox 360s, using metacritic, gamerankings, and IGN, if you cherrypick which source you want to use with each example.

You must think we're really dumb to actually believe that any of your propoganda is actually indicative of the failure or lackthereof of any game, much less a 360 exclusive. A game you are bound to despise simply because of the console it is released on.

Now I'll play your role, with your own ignorant logic(keep in mind, this is using his logic, and it is obviously an incorrect generalization, and I don't believe any of it for a second, this is just giving him a taste of his own medicine):

 

According to metacritic, for instance, the PS3 has had many failures this year, including Fallout 3 inferior version, Resisance 2, Disgaea, Valkyria(sucks compared to Final Fantasy and Fable 2), Haze, Socom, Motostorm. Again, only two exclusive titles even worth mentioning according to your gamerankings/metacritic deductions. There were all hyped to be "The best games ever" by PS3 fanboys. Next, according to IGN, Disgaea 3 is a total failure. It's one of the worst games released this gen. According to gamespot, the PS3 version of fallout 3 isn't even AAA, but the 360 version is. The only games worth playing this year on the PS3 were MGS4, and LPB, and LBP was marketed and created for kids and casuals. It can't even manage to stay live, with server issues.

Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice PlayStation 3 Game by NIS     IGN Score: 6.7

Banjo is better than that.

According to gamerankings, the Xbox 360 has 17 AAA titles.

The playstation 3 has 8.

Don't even get me started on the abyssimal sales of Playstation 3 exclusives. I hope you aren't looking forward to sequels for Disgaea or Valkyria sequels. They both absolutely suck compared to Final Fantasy, and their sales were/will be poor. Disgaea 3 wasn't even as good as Disgaea 2 or 1.

lol, SoCOM. I can't believe that game was even hyped.

1. Playstation 3: SOCOM: Confrontation (2008) 60%
Sony Computer Entertainment America

So, what we have is 4 AAA exclusives. Two on each platform, just this year. If we look at all the years, 360 is vastly ahead and the PS3 has a much worse library. The PS3 will need a much faster pace if it ever wants to wint he review race. Plus 360 still has a chance with L4D and TLR. Does the PS3 have any chances left this year? WKC is 09. If we look at multiplats, the PC360 multiplats are the only console exclusive mulitplats there are, so, yes, once again, PS3, gamerankings, IGN, and metacritic own Sony.

 

Welp, that is obviously all BS, but I have to speak a language Triplebph understands, ladies and gentlemen. The ignorant language of someone who has strange self serving points of view, and who places all their faith in critics numerical reviews.