Madden 08 reviews

[BenKenobi88]

Warlord_ said:
Maybe i jumped at the wii to harsh in my first post but it just pissed me off to see the reviews of such PS3 games get smashed the way they did.

If the wii is next gen in the way most players look at the market should the wii not be judged against the PS3/360 games, i can see how each game should be rated different for their consoles but the PS3 version is in direct competition to the 360 one and it's rated that way.

If people want to have the wii rated seperate from the 360/PS3 graphics wise then the 360/PS3 versions should not battle it out against each other, But compare it to last years model.

 Yeah, the PS3 got rated against the 360...but the PS3 is supposed to be MORE powerful than the 360.  When it does less, it's a bad thing...the PS3 Madden got low scores, arguably all on its own...meaning, the PS3 can do better than Madden '08, it probably deserves its low score.
The Wii is much weaker than the PS3 or 360...so when it produces decent graphics like in Madden '08 Wii, it's a good thing...nobody expects it to look better than 360...