The 1up review was positive, but their scale needs some work. It seems like R2 is a 88 - 92 type of game. Also, I am surprised that they gave Motor Storm 2 an A-.
This is a pretty good in-game picture. There are more posted here. The thread warns of spoilers. http://forums.gametrailers.com/showthread.php?t=612493
Thanks for the input, Jeff.