Should more games be rated AO?

[Final-Fan]

Legend11 said:

Final-Fan said:

Legend11 said:

Final-Fan said:
And speaking of RE4, yes there are chainsaw guys in the game and it's pretty damn gory but it's also quite rare; as I said, in GoW it's a default weapon and you are the one doing it, as well as having it done to you.

Credibility -10

And you're saying that a game with about six guys in the entire game who have the capability to kill you, gorily, with a chainsaw is equally bad as a game with a DEFAULT WEAPON capable of doing the same?

Wisdom -8

So a game in which you're sometimes forced to point a shotgun at someone's head and shoot, that has enemies with potato sacks on their heads and look like they came off the set of Texas Chainsaw Massacre coming at you with chainsaws, etc, and suddenly you're saying it matters who's using the chainsaw on who? You don't see how basically making excuses for a game might make people question you? Especially considering two of the consoles the game is on and some of your previous posts?

RE4 is very violent, there is no doubting that. But if you think it is more violent than Gears of War you are sadly mistaken. However RE4 is more disturbing and horrifying; see the edit to my last post.

[edit: And yes it does matter who is killing whom.]