Resistance 2, Gears 1.5, or, erm, Animal Crossing?

[Shura]

I think than here are many concepts wrong about r2 and gow 2, for example:

One guy says "ooo, RESISTANCE 2 an amazing improvement from the first one" so for him, it deserves to be called """RESISTANSE """2""". But that same guy says "dissapointing, gears 2 is almost the same as the first one, its just a "gears of war """1.5""". But, lets think than gears 1 its almost a perfect game, with an average of 94, while resistans its just a "good" shooter with an average of 86 (i dont remember).

So, that said, Which of both games MUST improve the most??? i think than the answer is obvious.