Japan First Day Sales (10/23)

[ClaudeLv250]

mrstickball said:
..Why is it, though, that the DS can sell tons of 3rd party games oh-so well, and the Wii can't?

The Wii has 29 games over 100,000 units. 12 are 3rd party.
Therefore 41% of titles are 3rd party. However, 3rd party sales, by volume accounts for a scant 13% of sales over 100,000 units sold. Is it just me, or is that crazy?

The DS on the other hand has 164 titles over 100,000 units. 101 are 3rd party, which equals out to 61% of titles over 100,000 being 3rd party. But the major difference is in volume sales: 33% of all volume sales are 3rd party -- Well over twice as many as Wii software.

And Zucas, the market isn't bad in Japan. It's selling far above & beyond what it has been for the comparable timeframe last gen. Sales are indeed down from last year, but how in Gods name would that excuse poor 3rd party sales when Nintendo is still making a killing?

For example: Hardware sales in 2003 were down from 2002's breakneck pace. The PS2, GC and Xbox were all down. How come that didn't effect 3rd parties then?

And why isn't the supposed crisis effecting DS 1st and 3rd party sales? 66% of all games over 100k on the DS this year are 3rd party - One of which (DQV) is a million seller. That should tell you that the DS is selling more 3rd party games than they have been - a direct contradiction to your statement.

Do the analysis. 3rd party games aren't selling on the Wii. They are on the DS.

You can argue the why's of it, but it's NOT the economy.

You're sounding like a broken record because you've been repeating this fanboy tripe every five days and it's starting to reek of desperation now.

Your first mistake was comparing the DS - a handheld starting its 4th year, that's overtaken the PS2 in numbers - to the Wii, which is still struggling to get decent 3rd party support, and has a 3rd of the install base to sell what little software its been getting. Anyone that frequents this site knows that such a comparison is completely asinine.

To top it off, you went through a complete fail manuever by using Tenchu (first day sales, no less) as an example. Tenchu hasn't been relevant in years. By using Tenchu, you basically set yourself up for disaster. Tenchu has left a trail of stinkers, including several on the PS2, one on the DS, and one on the 360. By scrutinizing the Wii you made your agenda pretty clear. You made no attempt to explain why Tenchu didn't sell on the PS2, didn't sell on the DS and didn't sell on the 360. You made a beeline for the Wii and pretended that Tenchu's history was irrelevant. And I can tell you right now, those games didn't perform that way because of a lack of numbers on the box.

And the PS2/Xbox/GC comparison was hilarious. Seriously, Gamecube and Xbox? They were almost completely ignored by 3rd parties. The PS2 had no problem because it had heavy 3rd party support right out of the gates. When the Wii gets swamped in Final Fantasy, Devil May Cry, and Dragon Quest games then we can start talking about 3rd party sales. But if your best material are Tenchu first day sales, you're grasping at straws, and making great headway at destroying what little credibility you had left.