The most overrated games of the year were GTA4 and MGS4 plain and simple. Both deserved scores around 9.5-9.8. I'm a huge MGS fan and when I saw all of the cut scenes, I was seriously amazed by the cinematic quality, but when I came to, I realized it takes too much from the game itself. The best MGS game is still one and then two, 4 comes next and then 3 is last. GTA4 was missing alot that should've been added. Rockstar is slowly milking the series and for that intentional fuck up by backtracking the game deserved to be degraded a couple points.