1up Boogie review, its not pretty.

[outlawauron]

shams said:

outlawauron said:

DKII said:
Seriously who uses 1up for Wii reviews? They pretty much blatantly hate the system and motion controls in general.

The same 1up that gave LoZ:TP three perfect 10s and the Game of the Year award. Ya ..... they sure are biased.

I don't agree with that either.

TP is good game, but it was nowhere near a 10 - and not even close to GOTY in my opinion.

...

Its not so much bias, as inconsistency. You can't do much better than comparing across the board scores of 1UP with that on gamerankings. A couple are too high, some are very close - and a lot of then are much lower than the norm.

TP = 10, RE4 = 8, Sonic = 7.5?

I agree that we should create a new thread to debate this in.

Either way, Boogie looks average at best. 

 

Sonic and the Secret Rings deserves a 7.5. RE4 would most likely have gotten higher if it would have had more than just Wii controls added on.

 My point is that they DON'T balantly hate the Wii.