questions for wii music haters. please answer truthfully( i know, im sorry)

[tuoyo]

woopah said:

im not a fan of wii music, i dont think it will be particularly amazing and i deff wont buy it. but:

 

1. how is it worse than wii fit? that seems like even less of a game to me and more of a fitness video

2. have you noticed that most hate about it being 'nothing but waggle' have come from threads not actual previews of the game

3. the SSBB/mario kart/wii fit trilogy didnt destroy gaming so why woulf the D:doc/animal crossing/wii music trilogy

4. as much as i hate to quote metacritic, wii sports got 76 and wii fit got 80, couldnt wii music get a similar score?

5. why has miyamoto gone crazy? his games have always been about more than just the hardcorz. he describes zelda as : a game that gives the player their own little garden to explore

From your thread title I think you must be talking to me.

1.  It is worse than Wii Fit because Wii Fit can be used for exercise.  It is also worse because that and Animal Crossing are all that we are going to have this Christmas.  When Wii Fit came out there were core Nintendo games to choose from.  It's also worse than Wii Fit because with Wii Fit you determined what happened in the exercises.  With Wii Music the Music just comes out.  You seem to have very little say.

2. I saw the E3 demonstration and they didn't seem to be doing anything other than pretending.  I can put on a cd grab my Wii remote, swing it around and pretend I am making music without having to waste money on Wii Music.

3.  I don't get your point.  How could Brawl or Mario Kart destroy gaming?  Or Disaster or Animal Crossing?  Our fear is that if Wii Music is super successful (in sales not in quality - it has as much chance of having great quality as I have of learning how to fly in the next 10 minutes) then Nintendo would spend too much time focusing on such games and less time on games like Brawl, Kart or Disaster.

4.  Wii Sports deserves to get 96% or more.  That it got 76% and Mario Kart got less than 90% shows that reviews of Wii games are generally retarded.  I couldn't care less what Wii Music gets.  It can get 100% for all I care.  Me personally I will be giving it a score of 5%.

5.  Miyamoto has not gone crazy.  He seems to be getting more and more intelligent and creative than ever before as hard as that is to believe given he was already the greatest of all time.  How could he come up with Pikmin from doing gardening?  That's just out of this world.  But I am selfish.  He has given casuals Wii Sports, Wii Play and Wii Fit.  He has only given me Zelda TP and Galaxy (I'm not sure he has much involvement in Mario Kart).  So rather than focusing on giving casuals Wii Music for Christmas his priority should have been to give me Pikmin 3.  I think I deserve more attention than the new gamer given I have spent more on Nintendo products than 40 of them put together ever will.