I would love to participate in your bet but....
I am not to sure of IGN's reviews anymore. I don't necessarily think they are biased, but i have issue with their scoring. The 360 reviewers tend to be really leanient and overlook major flaws of a game as long as it is fun. The PS team seem to grade much harder and demand a whole lot more of a game. The slightest imperfection will dock you .5 points.
Nevertheless, I will place my bet.
Resistance 2: 9.8
Gears of War 2: 9.3
Greatness Awaits
PSN:Forevercloud (looking for Soul Sacrifice Partners!!!)