This is a stupid question. There isn't one thing in this world that everyone likes, why would there be one game, even a classic one?
You may love SMB3 and remember playing it ground up, but show it to a 12 year old who's never played a 2D platformer and only PS2 games, they may think it's the most boring thing ever.
Super Mario 64 may be one of the greatest games ever that you think every gamer who plays in 3D place should love, but the Madden nuts might hate it (and despite what you think, just because you don't like the game doesn't make them not gamers).
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was a fantastic game that will probably never see a better, but what does that matter to people that don't like Zelda games.
Halo was supposed to be the game revolutionized FPS controls on a console but not nearly everyone likes it.
God of War was a fun game but many people found the gameplay dull and repetitive.
Street Fighter II is supposed to be the best fighting game ever but there are a good deal of people that just plain hate it.
