Tales of Vesperia Review Watch

[Torillian]

ZenfoldorVGI said:

Riachu said:

ZenfoldorVGI said:
...and just to be clear, I believe Eurogamer, and Edge magazine will both consign to giving Disgaea 3 and Tales of Vesperia 6/10s.

They gave MGS4 8/10s....6/10 is what you should expect.

Eurogamer and Edge base their scores on innovation, right?

 

 

So they say. Frankly, I'm not a fan. It seems like they are trying to change the way games are made with their reviews, punishing games that stick to the same old stuff, but better. It's ideological reviewing, as the reviews aren't based on fun, but rather, "Does your game help progress the industry."

 

Which means both Disgaea and Tales are going to get F'd in the A when it comes to those 2 reviewers.  I'm unsure though, sometimes it seems that they just have different tastes.  They gave Siren an 8, which I don't understand if they're going on innovation.