Metal Gear Solid
Link to the Past
Ocarina of Time
Final Fantasy VIII
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy VI
Vagrant Story
Final Fantasy Tactics
Resident Evil 4(recently upped from 9.5)
Super Mario World
Super Mario 64
Super Mario Brothers
Symphony of the Night
The Orange Box
Elite Beat Agents
Diablo II
Warcraft III
Fallout II
Call of Duty 4
Braid, Bioshock, Tekken Tag, and Chrono Trigger all come close. I chose FFTactics over Radiant Dawn just to be PC, and I chose FFVIII because everyone gets one fanboy pick(and because I think it's best in the series and most underrated but that's another argument). I also left out X and XII so my list would keep credibility, along with many other great games that are seconds and thirds in series. I kept Gears off the list because RE4 exists, and Halo/Counterstrike off the list because CoD 4 is better, but portal/HL2 combo pwns em both. IMO, Soulcalibur, KoToR, and Metroid Prime would be over-rated at 10/10, and so would GTAIII. Elite Beat Agents is probably questionable to many, but I stand by it. It stands out as possibly the most sheer fun I've ever had with a game.
I believe all of these games will stand up to the test of time, and are destined to become classics. I can't add Bioshock simply because I feel the game is just short of perfection, however, I certainly also believe that it is destined to become a great classic.
I don't need your console war.
It feeds the rich while it buries the poor.
You're power hungry, spinnin' stories, and bein' graphics whores.
I don't need your console war.
NO NO, NO NO NO.
