ok....that was an angry post....lol. But anyway, when Halo 3 launched, it had an attach rate of about 50% in the US (360's only strong hold):
http://www.joystiq.com/2007/12/17/halo-3-bought-by-52-of-us-xbox-360-owners/
And when I looked at attach rates, and compared it to what he was trying to make a talking point out of relative to the 360, that's when I compared the two different genres of games.
Edit: I forgot about Project Sylpheed.....is THIS game's "success" a contributing factor to SE's decision?








