By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Desroko on 04 August 2008
Edit Thread
Groucho said:
superchunk said:
@groucho, your entire logic is full of fallacy and it makes me question your entire story.

Sure, the bc on the Wii is a great feature and it did make me sell my gc early since I knew I could finish the gc games I wanted on the Wii, but to say that the bc is the only reason it has done well so far is just absurd.

 

Since when is my own opinion a "fallacy"? No where in my post did I state that my opinion was that of the majority. I merely posted it as an issue to consider.  Also, perhaps you'd like to quote the part where I claimed the Wii's success was due to BC, rather than BC being the primary reason I purchased my own Wii, and that I knew many that had done the same.

I will suggest this, however.  Sales of used GC games seem to have skyrocketed with the success of the Wii.  Due to the Wii's numbers you might think "of course they have", but I would go as far to say that, as a gamer, the Wii's lineup has not yet come even remotely close to the value of the GC's lineup, and I believe that the Wii has no appealing gamer-oriented lineup on the horizon.  At the same time, I don't believe that the majority of Wii purchasers are necessarily Nintendo fans of the past, as I am -- so perhaps the lack of interesting "hardcore" titles doesn't matter to most.

You can discount my opinion as you like. There are certainly reasons to do so. But claiming my opinion is "fallacy" is... out of line.

 

 An opinion is not a magical shield which protects you from criticism. They can be wrong, and in your case, your opinion that "the Wii has been losing styeam ever since it passed the GC's numbers" is certainly wrong.