Fatal Frame IV - I really like the series, I loved the trailer and I'm an enthusiast of Suda 51's work.
Animal Crossing - I like the game, I have a lot of friends who play and I will get to play it with my girlfriend online when I go away for grad school.
Tales of Symphonia 2 - Huge Tales of fan, loved the first one on the Game Cube.
Guitar Hero: World Tour - I don't have Rock Band and I'm dying to get this.
Star Wars: Lightsaber Duels - LIGHTSABER DUELS!
I coud go on, but we were supposed to stick with 5 games, so I did just that. Also, I chose to focus on games that will come out this year.