Super Mario Galaxy vs. Halo 3 - Which game will sell more units overall?

[Avinash_Tyagi]

Bodhesatva said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:

ckmlb said:
I think you are really overestimating Mario's sales.

Super Mario Galaxy:

Japan- 1,800,000 (Not casual enough to sell more)
USA- 3,500,000 (Will sell very well but not even close to non traditional titles)
Others- 2,000,000 (Will sell well)
Total- 7,300,000

Halo 3:

Japan- 150,000 (Only 360 hardcore and some adopters)
USA- 8,000,000 (Biggest 360 game of the year)
Others- 1,500,000 (Will sell well in the UK and Australia and decent in other parts)
Total- 9,960,000

Hahahahahaha, you really only expect 1.8 million in Japan for mario? Hahahahahahahahahaha

Mario 64 and Mario Sunshine each did less than that (Sunshine considerably so). It's not an outlandish claim, Avinash.

 Yes it is, N64 and GCN were not the Wii, they were never as successful as the Wii, now a system that was as successful as the Wii, has had a Super Mario game sell almost 5 million in Japan, i'm not saying galaxy will sell like NSMB, but to say it will sell as poorly as earlier mario's is ridiculous