Although no score is given, the impression is extremely positive:

"Some games I want to give a score, this is one of them, it promotes gaming as an interactive adventure and an art form, broadening what is possible on a gaming platform. For this alone it deserves acknowledgement, the fact that it controls so well and is very fun just compounds this to make it a great title in gaming history. It has it’s flaws but its ambition and quality features far out weigh the few issues. Naughty Dog has my permission to abstain from making cartoon games in the future to concentrate on cinematic titles such as this. Dust off the PS3 and get ready to jump around."

Look here for the full review 

So, no flop here! 

Good news everyone :P.
That does sound extremely positive.

Still to early to say flop or not.

@yojimbo, not a flop in terms of quality

It still just a one review. And I think that if this game is good it will also sell good, even if it don't break 100k openning week it should have some legs. There is still a little competition on PS3 platforms and most games are forgotten shortly after relase. The one exception is Resistance (and to some point Motorstorm - bad it's bundled so it's diffeerent story).

Yeah its a good review, and I think Uncharted will be a good game. But why would one small website no one's ever heard of get a review copy of uncharted weeks before ign or 1up or any playstation magazines

@ ngage sux maybe they just did their review based mainly on the previous previews, whereas IGN really take their time over the review, it is perfectly possible that they have got their review copy, but the game was finished last week. For the PlayStation magazine, their review will be avaliable on 21st November in the UK. For most games there is an embargo on reviews until a certain date, maybe it is only for the big sites

From what I've seen the game looks fantastic, together with R&C TOD certainly a game that truly pushes the PS3 into providing unique quality experiences. But even a game like Uncharted only uses about 1/3 of the Cell's potential, while planning the game design Naughty Dog didn't have a PS3 dev kit yet and of course only owned legacy game engines, so their next game is going to push the system much further as they now have had a good taste of what's possible and have a modern SPE enabled game engine they can improve upon.

WELL

it is Nuaght Dog making it

so I have no shred of doubt that this could be a very reliable review

ANOTHER HIT after R &C

Great to hear that the PS3 is getting a new great game :D