All you have to do is put what score you think the game mentioned below deserves, and write a brief explanation as to why it deserves that score.

Voting is open for 24 hours, after the 24 hour period I will count up all the scores and get the average of the game.  I will be putting up a new thread with a new game every24-48 hours depending on how big the thread is.

Rules:

1. You had to have played at least enough of the game to form a opinion about it.

2. Users with less than 100 posts cannot score a game unless they give a good description as to why they think the game should get the score they gave.

3. scores have to be on a 10 point scale, and anything longer than 2 digits (EG: 9.8) won't be counted.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Today's game is Metal Gear Solid 4!

And the score is 9.52!!   

I haven't played a whole lot of this game, but from what I have played I would give it a 8.8

+ Cutscenes are extremely well done, Graphics are among the best, The game can get pretty intense.

-  Kinda confusing story, And i'm not really a big fan of stealth games.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vgchartz top 20 rated games

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Metal Gear Solid 4-9.52

2. Batman: Arkham Asylum-9.01

3. Halo 3: ODST-8.95

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tomorrows game: Dirt 2!

9.6

+ atmosphere, story, graphics, gameplay... pretty much everything
- replayability: although there are plenty of ways to play and solve problems, it's not a game that you can play over and over again.

9.9

+ Storyline, gameplay, graphics, sound, bosses, replayability
- Some insanely convoluted plot lines and extensive cutscenes, installs

9.9
+graphics, gameplay, story and cutscenes. Online is really fun.
-Length of actual game

9.8
+ story, graphics, gameplay, re playability if you want all the emblems. ties all the MGS together.
- online is horrible. Thats pretty much it. It actually ends!!!!!

8.8

+ Interesting storyline, great graphics and fun gameplay. 
- Very little replay value, very confusing storyline for those unfamiliar with MGS.

9.6

+ story, gameplay, cutscenes, music, camera, graphics, dialogs.
- could be longer, not as good as MGS 1 and 3, some textures could be better (specially in the first levels), few innovations since MGS 1, too much and too long installs, frequent loadings, the end of the saga ( ? ), no trophies.

9.0

+ Story, graphics, good replay value
- The AI is a little thick at times, the controls (I found them hard at least), on the easier difficulty settings you can just go in all guns blazing

10.0

Pro's : Graphics , Audio , Gameplay, Replayability, but most of all the Story. I knew nothing about the MGS series except Snake was the main character. After I beat the game, I felt like I knew everything about the MGS series.

Con's : Cutscene lengths, and frequent install times.

9.6/10

+ Presentation, Story, Gameplay, Audio, Replay value, Freedom of choice
- Very little use of the codec compared to past games.