The List
-------------------------
22 IGN(+++)

15 GameTrailers

12 Famitsu

11 Computer & Video Games
11 EGM Magazine

10 Play UK Magazine
10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 X-Play

9 Gaming Target (-)
9 Video Game Talk (-)
9 Game Vortex (-)
9 Cheat Code Central (-)
9 Game Informer Magazine(-)
9 Play Magazine (-)

8 Yahoo Games

7 Gaming Rankings
7 GameSpy
7 GameShark

4 Edge Magazine

Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

PS: You can't always vote 3 negative points to a site since sites at 1 or 2 can't take 3 negative points.

 I think people would trust the user reveiws here if they were limitted to one vote per user, only members could vote, and the voted scores were public, or at least the moderators could reveiw them.

IE: If some gives a game that averages a 9 only a 3, the moderator could then look for a pattern of abuse, etc... and pull all the users votes.  (or just leave all the votes public, and users will report the abuse...)

The List
-------------------------
22 IGN

15 GameTrailers

12 Famitsu

11 Computer & Video Games
11 EGM Magazine

10 Play UK Magazine
10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 X-Play
10 GameSpy (+++)

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex
9 Cheat Code Central
9 Play Magazine

8 Yahoo Games

7 Gaming Rankings
7 GameShark

6 Game Informer Magazine (---)

1 Edge Magazine (---)

Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

PS: You can't always vote 3 negative points to a site since sites at 1 or 2 can't take 3 negative points.

Sorry ssj12 but I'll always use Gamerankings above any individual review source.

22 IGN

15 GameTrailers

12 Famitsu

11 Computer & Video Games
11 EGM Magazine

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 X-Play
10 GameSpy
10 Gamerankings (+++)

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex
9 Cheat Code Central

8 Yahoo Games


7 GameShark
7 Play UK Magazine (---)
6 Play Magazine (---)

6 Game Informer Magazine


Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

PS: You can't always vote 3 negative points to a site since sites at 1 or 2 can't take 3 negative points.

I forgot what Play magazine was awful so I voted both down XD

I think you voted one too many minuses Rath...you have 6...plus you killed edge.

25 IGN( + + + )

15 GameTrailers

12 Famitsu

11 Computer & Video Games
11 EGM Magazine

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 X-Play
10 GameSpy
10 Gamerankings (+++)

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex
9 Cheat Code Central

8 Yahoo Games


7 GameShark
7 Play UK Magazine

3 Play Magazine (- - - )
3 Game Informer Magazine ( - - - )

Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

lol...this is too funny. SSJ12...u best get in here and fix the posts or this is going to get out of control...lol. Threads like these always require at least one person to monitor the votes and make sure everything is ok. RolStoppable has done it, Fina-Fan has done...and I'm not going to do it...lol. Your thread SSj12...time to come in and clean up.

Oh whoops

Next person add one to UK Play please? I voted -7 instead of -6.

AsylumX fixed your mistake Rath.