By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - which top 10 list is best?

What system do you think has the best top 10 list recently posted on this site?

 

I was surprised by the strength of both the ps3 and wii top 10. I figured 360 would get the win there but i think 360 is only slightly higher quality than ps3, but for me the wii takes the win. i have 6 of the games on the wii list but i want the other 4 a lot. I don't own the 360 or ps3 but i've played some of those top games and i would only want probably 7 of the games on each list. Plus the wii list has the most variety with lots of genres represented, ps3 has good variety, while the 360 doesn't have much variety at all (half of the game are fps or 3rd person shooters).

On a side note, 360 still probably has the best depth outside of the top 10, with wii having decent depth. PS3 i'd say not only has the worst top 10 but also the worst depth, i can't think of a single game not listed in the ps3's top 10 that i would think is worth buying.

Another interesting thing going along with the variety of games. for the ps3 8 of those 10 are games are gun shooting games (including warhawk since you can get on foot and the planes shoot guns), 360 has 7 of its games on the list as gun-wielding games, and for the wii there's 2 games where you shoot guns. not saying shooting games aren't great, and most of those on the list are really good games but that lack of variety in the focus of games even among different genres is kinda sad.

Top 10 lists:

Wii: http://news.vgchartz.com/news.php?id=2378

360: http://news.vgchartz.com/news.php?id=2351

PS3: http://news.vgchartz.com/news.php?id=2358



end of '08 predictions: wii - 43 million,  360 - 25 million, ps3 - 20 million

 

Games I've beat recently: Super Mario Galaxy, Knights of the Old Republic, Shadow of the Collossus

 

Proud owner of wii, gamecube, xbox, ps2, dreamcast, n64, snes, genesis, 3DO, nes, atari, intellivision, unisonic tournament 2000, and gameboy

Around the Network

Hmmm. I want 3 for the Wii and 4 for the PS3. I have 8 of the 360 ones. The PS3 count isn't completely fair though, as there are 3 on the PS3 I already have on the 360.

Different strokes for different folks I guess, I'm sure there are many who will post that agree and disagree with you. The cost of the Wii, means I will probably get one before I pick up a PS3 though.



I like the wii one the best





  

Ummm you have to remember these top ten lists are compiled purely on the opinions of a select few. Take into account the demographic that frequents this site. People that tend to like shooters are westerners and are core gamers and guess what their consoles of choice are? What kind of people do you think make up the majority of the visitors and moderators of this site? And with this in mind you can probably now gauge why VC staff tend to favour shooters on HD consoles.



The Wii one because neither the PS3 or X360 has one of its games.



Around the Network

< My favorite console > has the best list because < stupidly inane reason >.


Watch above and below as people fill in the blanks.



jkl2207 said:
Ummm you have to remember these top ten lists are compiled purely on the opinions of a select few. Take into account the demographic that frequents this site. People that tend to like shooters are westerners and are core gamers and guess what their consoles of choice are? What kind of people do you think make up the majority of the visitors and moderators of this site? And with this in mind you can probably now gauge why VC staff tend to favour shooters on HD consoles.

Most if not all of the VC staff own a wii.  And from what i have read they are not big shooter fans.  The only shooting games they seem to like are Valve ones.

 



Griffin said:
jkl2207 said:
Ummm you have to remember these top ten lists are compiled purely on the opinions of a select few. Take into account the demographic that frequents this site. People that tend to like shooters are westerners and are core gamers and guess what their consoles of choice are? What kind of people do you think make up the majority of the visitors and moderators of this site? And with this in mind you can probably now gauge why VC staff tend to favour shooters on HD consoles.

Most if not all of the VC staff own a wii.  And from what i have read they are not big shooter fans.  The only shooting games they seem to like are Valve ones.

By "VC staff" you mostly mean Naznatips and BenKenobi88.



the 3 fo them are great!, but i'll say the wii's list is the best. Why? Because i own the Wii!



MY ZELDA COLLECTION

Wii is the best list imo because ps3 and 360 lists have many multiplatform titles.