Predict the Metacritic scores of the Xbox 360's holiday blockbusters!

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Predict the Metacritic scores of the Xbox 360's holiday blockbusters!

Fable 2 87!?, Starcraft how dare you make that prediction, you are the operator of the Fable 2 hype machine, your actions are completely irresponsible.

I'm going for 98 on Fable 2, if GTA could get 98, there is no reason Fable 2 can't. After all it is a ground breaking and innovative game with the potential to be one of the all-time greats. Trust me on this, Fable 2 is going to be unparalleled. I'm sorry but Gears and Fallout don't even compare.

Currently Playing: Gears 2, World at War, GTA IV, Banjo Nuts and Bolts

The Greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge - Stephen Hawking


Around the Network

I honestly think that with the co-op delay it's scores will slip.

What can I say?

starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

Prince of Persia- 92
Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts: 79- 90, unsure. Either way I will like it alot.
Fable 2: 94
Gear of wars 2: 95

Fable 2 90% - Reviewers will give it a higher score than it deserves because they don't want to get a letter from Molyneux crying about why they gave it not a 9.

Banjo Kazzoie --- 81% --- Will be seen as a good game but not for the fans who loved platforming.

Gears Of War 2 --- 92% --- Will be seen as a great improvement...with brilliant online modes & story

Fable 2 --- 89% --- Will be seen as HUGE improvement over Fable 1...but they will moan bout something

Left 4 Dead --- 92% --- Valve is making it....even though I think it looks bland, generic & boring....reviewers will gobble it up like turkish delight.

as you are sayin SR2 is a "360 blockbuster" I'm adding other multiplat blockbusters too:

Saints Row 2 -- 83% -- they will call it a wannabee GTA....it will suffer the same fate as LO.

COD WOW -- 85% -- not as good as COD4

POP -- 90 -- a great return for the franchise

All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network

Not going to give my opinions on the games but what I think they'll average around..


Gears of War 2: 94
Fable 2: 88
Banjo: 82
Left 4 Dead: 90


Fallout 3: 93
Farcry 2: 90
Dead Space: 92
Mirror's Edge: 88


LittleBigPlanet: 94
Resistance 2: 91

Completed X360:
High Def Movie Collection

Gears 2- 94

Fable 2- 89

Banjo- 78

Left 4 Dead- 91

Saints Row 2- 83

Alright, I'll bite. (Ohm nom nom nom etc.)

Gears of War 2: 93

Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts: 84

Fable 2: 88

Left 4 Dead: 90

Saints Row 2: 85

Wii Music: 100

Gears of War 2: 96

Fable 2: 1

Banjo Kazooie 3: 85

Left 4 Dead: 89

Saint's Row 2: 83

Why do people believe Gears 2 will do better than Fable 2? Fable looks much much better, Gears doesn't seem like anything new, but could reach 90 anyway for being polished.