Just finished up The Avengers, and man I have to say I kind of forgot why I loved this movie so much. I always knew it was one of my top three Marvel movies, but I kept trying to tell myself why I was being foolish for it since 'it wasn't all that'.
I was wrong. This movie was amazing.
The special effects were outstanding and mostly hold up today, the action sequences are still out of this world (The battle of Manhattan remains one of the best superhero action sequences ever), and the soundtrack is near perfection, but that's not why I love this movie. You could take out the action and audio, and this movie would still be outstanding.
Why? The writing.
The dialogue was snappy and incredibly well done, the plot hit all the right notes, the character work was - again - absolutely phenomenal, the story had foreshadowing, thematic throughlines, tight structure, a combination of subtlety and bombast, humor, seriousness, tragedy, and everything in between. Joss Whedon balanced a half dozen disparate characters with deftness and wit, he managed to give every character something to do to better personify them without sacrificing the others, and he made them play off each other so well that it really is leagues above pretty much all other movie franchises out there.
Also, for anyone saying the banner/natasha romance was sudden in Avengers 2, I recommend going back to watch this movie. It's not overt, it's not blatant, but the budding romance is totally there from the first time they meet. It's kind of sweet.
I really don't have any complaints. like I said, the writing was on point, the character interactions and development were all handled well, the action was top notch, the score was a modern classic, the cinematography was somehow better than even Thor and Captain America, I loved everyone in the movie (even Loki), and....gruh!
What a truly wonderful movie. This is why the MCU is quite possibly my favorite movie franchise. Movies like this are why I'm so disappointed in DC for failing so miserably. I don't want to take potshots at them, it feels cheap, but when you have a blueprint for success and quality and you still muss it up, I have to question your ability to make films.
I guess the only 'complaint' that I have to address is that it's a little jokey. yeah, there are a lot of jokes, yeah it's a funny movie, but if you're the kind of person who thinks cracking a few jokes (especially coming from wisecracking folks like Tony Stark and Nick Fury) is bad? Then what are you doing watching superhero movies? Not only does it keep the audience with a hint of levity, but it serves to better show character.
Plus, being funny doesn't mean it can't also be serious. Tone is not a zero sum game. The movie is funny when it needs to be, somber when it needs to be, and tense when it needs to be. That's called balance.
Anyway, at this point I'm just sucking Joss Whedon's dick.
9.5/10
One of the highest film scores I've ever given. I think maybe a half dozen movies in history have gotten a 9.5 or more out of me. (no I won't list them, most of them are movies most folks don't like).
My ranking so far:
9.5 The Avengers
9.1 Captain America: The First Avenger
9.0 Iron Man
8.9 Iron Man 2
8.3 Thor
6.1 The Incredible Hulk
Gonna take a few days off while my brother keeps up. He and I are going to watch Phase 2 and Phase 3 together over the net. .