Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Would you Prefer a Remake of Gen IV or Another One of Gen I

Gen I or Gen IV?

Gen I
Gen IV
Another Gen
Yerm said:
Sinnoh had a lot of problem. the gameplay was slower, the progression system was slow and unbalanced, and the pokemon were a bit lack-luster. thats why it SHOULD be remade. with modern hardware and mechanics we could get a definitive Sinnoh game.

meanwhile we have the Kanto region. the most overused region EVER.

Gen I - main game based in Kanto
Gen II - entire Kanto region was updated and playable in Gold, Silver, and Crystal
Gen III - Kanto region entirely remade in Fire Red & Leaf Green
Gen IV - updated and remade in Heart Gold and Soul Silver
Gen V - first generation in FIFTEEN years to not feature the Kanto region at all
Gen VI - Kanto starters are made available in addition to new starters
Gen VII - the Kanto region is referenced every 10 minutes and the original games are now on VC.

yeah, im too nostalgic about Gen I. in fact, I feel like it holds the series back. Gen V was the best generation they ever made, and it the first and only time nothing from Kanto was used. we cant just keep reusing it over and over and over again.

I can agree with this.



We're really gonna be able to jack up our price if we're two-time galaxy savers!

Around the Network
I would much rather a sequel to the Kanto region, as opposed to a remake once more, ala Black and White 2, to which I actually hated, I hate you Speedo Pig evo line... forcing me to choose the non fire type for the first time ever... sorry, rage building.

Why hate systems that bring you great games?

PSN: Aceburg0413

XBOX Live: Sheep of Doom13

Nintendo:  SheepofDoom13

3DS FC:  3222 - 5562 - 9867

aceburg0413 said:
I would much rather a sequel to the Kanto region, as opposed to a remake once more, ala Black and White 2, to which I actually hated, I hate you Speedo Pig evo line... forcing me to choose the non fire type for the first time ever... sorry, rage building.

Oh please. Fire types almost always suck. After Charizard, the only ones that were *decent* were Typhlosion and Delphox... Infernape, ehh. Maybe.

The other ones are awful. Grass and Water starters are where it's at.



We're really gonna be able to jack up our price if we're two-time galaxy savers!

Go figure, Typhlosion and Delphox are my two favorite evo lines. Though I don't play for the tourney scene, as my breeding love has been a perfect Fennekin, Milotic and skill link Ciniccino.

Why hate systems that bring you great games?

PSN: Aceburg0413

XBOX Live: Sheep of Doom13

Nintendo:  SheepofDoom13

3DS FC:  3222 - 5562 - 9867

mZuzek said:
aceburg0413 said:
I would much rather a sequel to the Kanto region, as opposed to a remake once more, ala Black and White 2, to which I actually hated, I hate you Speedo Pig evo line... forcing me to choose the non fire type for the first time ever... sorry, rage building.

Oh please. Fire types almost always suck. After Charizard, the only ones that were *decent* were Typhlosion and Delphox... Infernape, ehh. Maybe.

The other ones are awful. Grass and Water starters are where it's at.

If you talk design alone, sure, whatever floats your boat. But gameplay-wise Blaziken is the single-most useful and powerful starter of all, not just fire types alone. Its even banned from most competitive tiers cause its so broken. -_- 

 



Only speed boost Blaziken is as far as I know.

Why hate systems that bring you great games?

PSN: Aceburg0413

XBOX Live: Sheep of Doom13

Nintendo:  SheepofDoom13

3DS FC:  3222 - 5562 - 9867

Gen 4 remakes are almost guaranteed to happen, its just a matter of when. As for gen 1, please don't do it. We just got the first games on 3ds e-shop. Remaking the blandest and smallest region on Switch is wasted potential.


I wouldn't mind a Gen 1 re-remake, but would prefer a different remake (Gen 4) or a new game/sequel..

Platinum is my favourite Pokemon game :p


Nintendo Metascore | Official NintenDomination | VGC Tutorial Thread

              

 

 

Here lies the hidden threads. 

 | | | Best and Worst of Miiverse | Manga Discussion Thead |
[3DS] Winter Playtimes [Wii U]

Generation I remakes would be ridiculous. So much nostalgia packed into one game that people can't see that they really aren't all that amazing. (And they've happened already.) Generation IV remakes would be worth it and would also benefit greatly from new graphics considering the sizable leaps that have been made since 2006.

Carl is a Piplup hater and deserves to be punished eternally.

Around the Network
Gen IV, but only if it includes all the Platinum content.
Pok Platinum>>>>>>>>>>>>>>R/B


Gaga cured me