Star Tropics, Ice Climbers, The Frog For Whom the Bell Tolls, Eternal Darkness,  Earthbound

Definitely Earthbound or Eternal Darkness.

Eternal Darkness with Earthbound close behind. both I'm excited for. I sort of want to say F-Zero too, although I guess I don't want a 'reboot' just another sequel...

technically speaking there are a tonnnnnnn of old Nintendo 1st Party Gameboy titles that could be rebooted too

Eternal darkness or earthbound

I think startropics has potential to reach outside nintendos normal demographic

Eternal Darkness.

The Mother series doesn't need a new game. It will live on through legacy as one of the most fondly remembered series out there, and as a symbol of how far we've come in terms of video game localization. The other games are long dead, they have very little reason to live again. StarTropics has a slight bit more potential than the other two, anyway.

Earthbound without a doubt

The Frog For Whom the Bell Tolls, nobody's gonna vote for this one but it's a really good Gameboy game. I'd like to see an eshop reboot of the series just for fun.

I don't want to vote for Earthbound because it's never going to happen...so...I guess Eternal Darkness.

Star Tropics!

Those games were something, especially the first one.

Star Tropics & Eternal Darkness pls