Definitely Club Nintendo.

My Nintendo has practically nothing so far. And it's only been available for a few weeks, unlike Club Nintendo, which had the better part of a decade here in NA to prove itself. So I'd say we should wait at least a year until we can make a good judgement on which one is better.

You are comparing a program that has more than 5 years of existence, with one that has less than 1 month.Give it 1 year and then compare.Not every reward program can start giving out high-profile games for free out of the gate.And My Nintendo will probably get really good when NX comes out

I don't get the point of people asking this already (I've seen it here and other places). Just give it some time and see how it is in the future.

Too early to say, but My Nintendo is going down the right path.. just not there yet

Club Nintendo so far.

My Nintendo so far is crap imo. The only real rewards are discounts... So you don't even get rewards, it's just a incentive to make you buy more cause you have a discount.

It's still too early to tell. What did you guys get from Club Nintendo during the first few weeks? I'd say give it by the end of the year since E3 is around the corner and Nintendo should have more planned once things settle down with Miitomo, My Nintendo, and more.

Club Nintendo was 14 years old from the top of my head in most parts of Europe and in Japan and I had supported it almost since the start and gotten many cool things. My Nintendo is just starting, but no, I'm not exactly warming up to it yet because it offers nothing. We'll see how it develops.

So far club nintendo but it's not fair to compare them at this moment.