By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Rejoice, its not Episode 1 again, Star Wars is great (no spoilers inside)

jake_the_fake1 said:
SvennoJ said:
jake_the_fake1 said:

So I just came back from watching the movie, and suffice to say that deus ex machinas are rampant and in your face, not even the force can explain the stupidity that was on show, people with no skills in certain things all of a sudden becoming proficient as if they downloaded that skill set out of thin air, couple that with poor character development for main characters and what essentially amounts to a retelling of the original movies (episodes 4,5,6) but crappier cuz of time constraints....and that makes for a terrible movie, what saved it a little for me and moved it into the mediocre level was the nostalgia of old characters, some genuine funny moments, action sequences and visual effects.

So, without the PC part, that sounds exactly like what Abrams did to Star Trek, which was still loved by many people. (I thought it was an ok action movie, not really star trek) Curious what he's going to pick for episode 8, can't retell the prequels next.

 

looks like JJ will only do episode 7, Rian Johnson will be directing episode 8 and 9, he Directed Looper, I like that movie so maybe in terms of directing episode 8 will be ok, but it's the story I'm worried about.

 

Looper was ok, not that big on story. But if you like Looper, you should watch Predestination. It's more story focussed and much better imo. Best not to know anything about it before watching, simply enjoy.



Around the Network

Tomorrow the Force will be with me.



jake_the_fake1 said:


Also, WTF is up with that 50/50 gender representation in almost every scene, it feels forced, like if their was some quota or agenda that needed to be met by Disney, and this occurs on both sides. I'd assume the the First order, an Authoritarian regime, wouldn't have that, cuz you know their evil and all, but no they like the rebellion seem to be very progressive....also I laughed at the female storm trooper, did they seriously have to make her so shiny, also why bother with her since she like all storm trooper are faceless cannon fodder for the rebellion forces, it's funny though cuz they still can't aim for shit.

Another thing that stood out is how diverse the rebellion forces were, and I'm just talking about the humans having almost every race represented and yet the First Order were just white, except for that one black storm trooper whom we get to see his face in the trailers. It's odd to me that the First Oder, being evil, has 50/50 gender representation and yet doesn't have the same diversity in races, kinda racist if you ask me.

What? If you felt "gender representation was forced" you must have been looking for it the entire movie.

This is a load of BS.





This movie has me sad. It is very very much a rehash of A New Hope. They should have called it A Newest Hope to imform movie goers that this is as original as the Robocop remake. That being said, it is a good movie, but under the OT and RoTS.



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!


WolfpackN64 said:
jake_the_fake1 said:


Also, WTF is up with that 50/50 gender representation in almost every scene, it feels forced, like if their was some quota or agenda that needed to be met by Disney, and this occurs on both sides. I'd assume the the First order, an Authoritarian regime, wouldn't have that, cuz you know their evil and all, but no they like the rebellion seem to be very progressive....also I laughed at the female storm trooper, did they seriously have to make her so shiny, also why bother with her since she like all storm trooper are faceless cannon fodder for the rebellion forces, it's funny though cuz they still can't aim for shit.

Another thing that stood out is how diverse the rebellion forces were, and I'm just talking about the humans having almost every race represented and yet the First Order were just white, except for that one black storm trooper whom we get to see his face in the trailers. It's odd to me that the First Oder, being evil, has 50/50 gender representation and yet doesn't have the same diversity in races, kinda racist if you ask me.

What? If you felt "gender representation was forced" you must have been looking for it the entire movie.

This is a load of BS.



 

Looking for it no,  it was just blatantly obvious, the forced part is in reference to each scene have 50/50. Don't know how you could of missed it since it's right their in your face, but hey some people can be oblivious to certain things, it's only natural. But if you don't believe then, or think I'm talking BS, then I compel you to go see the movie again, I'm pretty certain you'll see what I'm talking about even if you admit or not.

I guess I may have just given you the excuse to go see the movie again, i would like your opinion on you second watch.





Around the Network
DakonBlackblade said:
jake_the_fake1 said:

1. 

2.

3. 

4. .

5. 

6. 

7. 

8.  

9. 

10. 

11. 

Your points 10 and 11 is all spoilers, delete it plz or add tags warnings and whatnot, I asked to keep this spoiler free on the OP. about point 11, ye some things are too coincidental in the movie, but again The Force is a thing and it does conect everyone and things happen because of it, random shit has been happening in SW universe since its inseption due to the Force trying ot keep itself balanced.

1. You arent disliking the movie youre hating for political reasons mostly, they way you describe your experience with it feels like you went to the theaters wanting to hate it ever since you saw the poster and there was 1 woman 1 black dude and 1 white dude in it (and chewbaka for added "diversity").

2 Ye there is but what does that have to do with anything ? Rey happened to be a woman cause she got 2 X chromososmes when she was an embryo, theres like 0 political underlines to her, shes a woman and shes in the story, her character works so end of discussion.

3 The story is familiar but its well told, and there are quite a few differences. JJ played it safe, the movie needed to work to get things going, it worked, 94% on Rotten Tomatoes and overwhelmingly posite fan reaction shows just how much it worked. The fact that you cant see 1 positive point on the movie shows you had a pre disposition to dislike it, even Twilight have some good points, its more than obvious that this movie does as well.

4 It is a point worth mentioning cause youre hating on the so called "50/50" representation for no reason, so I reminded you the actors did theyre job brilliantly.

5 Theoretically the 1st order has all kinds of ppl as they recruit by kidnapping younglings and brainwashing them (like they did to Finn) and from the 5 1st order guys with no helmet, counting Finn, 1 is black, 1 is a woman, 1 is an allien and 2 are white males so your point makes no sense.

6 The whole saga has flaws, even the books do, but its clear youre exagerating.

7 Youre hatting on everything, theres a clear difference between critique and hate for the sake of hate. Your post does make one think you watched the movie with a pre concieved notion you were gona dislike it for whatever reason, the  "50/50"representation being one of those reasons most likely.

8 Glad you agree theyre good actors

9 Theres no infusion of nothing, whats wrong with the dude being black and Rey being a woman, seriously whats the difference, there are various races and genders on the world, is it that impossible to acept Rey and Finn just happened to be whoever they are ? Yoda is a green pupet and ppl didnt give him a hard time... Again the sotry is wellcrafted, has some flaws, but it is, and the movie has mostly pratical effects (its noticeable), theres very little CG on it considering todays standards.

10 Thats how the Force works, you say you didnt watch the prequels and a bunch of other stuf so dont act like you know the lore. Anakin Skywalker was able to win a Pod Racing event at the age of 9, even tough he wasnt an acomplished pod racer, he was regarded as one the best marksman in the jedi order, amongst the best lightsaber duelist and pretty much just did anything he tried to do well, he could also understand any language. When someone is strong with the force, shit happens, it happened to Luke too but Luke was never this strong, Anakin was more powerfull than him,Vader was super powerfull and he only had a fraction of Anakins full potential cause of all the limbs he lost and the injurys he sustained in his duel with Obi Wan on Episode 3. The person you mention doesnt realy know what he is doing but he feels the conection with the force and just go with it, outbursts of excelency happens due to The Force as well, an example again from the prequels you didnt watch is Kenobi killing Darth Maul, a Sith so powerfull he defeated Qui Gon Jinn, Kenobis master and a jedi regarded as one of the best lightsaber duelists ever to live, Kenobi was a padawan back there and he managed to best Maul after seing his master die because he was that strong with Force, in a moment of need/desperation he managed to acess this power of his without realy knowing what he was doing, sounds familiar ? Its made very clear this person you talk about is realy powerfull (in very clever and subtle ways), about the person being OP I doubt it, theres always powerfull enemys on the universe that could match this person and Eps 8 and 9 havent happened yet.

Sorry about the spoiler thing, I figured people would follow the conversation and know it may be headed towards spoiler territory since the person I was replying to had spoilers in their post, but as suggested I've added spailer marks to points 10 and 11.

1. No, if you read point 3, and which I iterated on point 7, I was criticising the story, the poor character development, and the deus ex machinas and it's these reasons why I disliked the movie. Me pointing out political correctness was just pointing out the obvious since it stuck out like a sore thumb but it itself  had no bearing on the story, character development, or deus machina.

2.  That's the problem, when looking at the micro scale of just the one movie, one could argue that's it's just a female lead and nothing more, I would tend to agree with you since it could just be a narrative choice, but once you zoom out to the maco and see the larger picture, it seems to be happening across the board. For some examples take a look at the recent fantastic 4 movie, Johnny Storm The Human Torch, he was white but now they made him black cuz reasons, or how about Salt with Angelina Jolie, it was originally a male character in the books but now female in the movie cuz reasons, or how about Mad Max? where Max was religated to a background character in his own supposed movie, like I said this is now becoming a trend.  In regards to Mad Max I actually liked the movie, but I think it would of been better served had they just cut out  Max and focused on Furiosa's back story rather than waist it on max who...well...was poorly written and just took up valuable time, They could of released another mad max movie staring max himself, with a 3rd movie were they both team up or something....you know like a new trilogy, I mean it could still be done but I doubt it.

To sum up my point, it seems like if a movie tries to cater towards the male demographic they need to hamfist in females cuz reasons, the market is clearly big enough for movies to cater to everyone without the need to hamfist and gender bend, or race bend characters because of politocal correctness. Black characters exist, female characters exist, so make their own movies. I'd love to see another spawn movie with Al simmons, I'd love to see a dedicated movie to Marvels Black panther, or how about a dedicated moive of wonder woman. If they fail due to market forces then so be it, but if they succeed then it's a win win for everybody, the more movie diversity as a whole the better, but trying to homogenise everything takes away from the potential unique characters and story lines that could be told, but hey this is just my opinion on the matter.

3. I do agree that JJ played it safe, I wish he didn't and would have taken a risk but we got what we got. Also I wouldn't take rotten tomatoes as gospel, there are many terrible movies which are highly rated like Indiana Jones & The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull and Justin Bieber: Never Say Never, as for why it worked, that's simple, tons of advertisment and nostalgia with the hope of having a good star wars movie after the prequels would do that, which is why I suggest that people to remove the nostalgia goggles for a bit when looking at this movie. Your wrong about me not liking certain parts of the movie, just read my original post, I literally wrote "...what saved it a little for me and moved it into the mediocre level was the nostalgia of old characters, some genuine funny moments, action sequences and visual effects."

4. I never once criticised the actors or their performance, in fact I agree with you, they did a fantasitc job, so why you brought this up is beyond me, and again I only pointed out the 50/50 representation because it looked ham fisted and forced,also because it seemed half assed when it came to the First Order and their representation or lack their of.

5. My whole point was the portrayal of white people being evil with the only black guy, Fin, shown to swap sides, while I agree that the first order do kidnap and brainwash children for their army from any race, gender, or species, what they actually showed however was just whites in charge. Again I brought this up because race doesn't mean anything when were talking about intergalactic species and yet the rebellion had clear race distictions shown as good where as the first order had only whites shown shown as evil.

6. I agree with you, as for me exagerating, it's possible but after sleeping on it I feel the same way, simply the movie didn't click with me like it did with others, I may be in the minority here, but so were the people who disliked Lord of the rings, harry potter, twilight, and the hunger games, all very popular movies, like I said it's only natural.

7. Nope you are projecting here, by your logic I should of hated sense8 and fear the walking dead since they had political correctness all over them, and yet I liked those shows, why because the story lines were good, the character development was good. Like I said, me pointing out the political correctness was becuase it looked forced and stuck out like a sore thumb, but had the story and character development been good I woudn't have cared, but it's exactly here where it failed for me.

8. Yep, never said otherwise.

9. I don't know why your so fixated in me pointing out the political correctness, it just something that stuck out for me, it was a throw away coment on my part because of the general trends I'm seeing in all forms of media with political correctness going overboard, so much so that even south parks dedicated their last season to mocking it. The problem is that a genuine works of fiction with female or black characters could be written or released as a movie and it would look no different from the movies that have been forced to gender/race bend characters just to meet the standards of political correctness, and this is a detriment to the media not a bonus. But like I've said in point 7 just above, had this movie actually had good character development with a better more unique story line, then yeah I would have enjoyed despite the political correctness.

I mean how hard would it have been to kill off Poe and Fins character and focus all that time on Rey and her discovery of the force, this in my opinon would have removed the deus ex machinas in the current release, or how about kill off Poe to dedicate more time to Fin and develop his background of why he choose to swap sides other than 'he felt it was right', I mean it's pretty big decision for him cuz if the first order found out he probably would of been killed, so more time spent on it would have been better, but that's just me.

10. I don't remember the force working like that in the original movies, not when luke was learning how to use it, I still remember that scene in the Wampa ice cave in episode 5, where luke is upside down in threat of being eaten and he has to use the force to get his lightsaber, it's not like he just used the force and thats that, he struggled to use the force since it was still new to him. In the originals the force is like training a muscle, the more you use it the better you are with the force, but now in episode 7 it's like the matrix, if you have the force just download the skill sets required and your good to go.....which is dumb and makes deus ex machina just that more obvious to see. Also  I never claimed to know the whole lore of the star wars universe, I just mentioned the lore I know based off episodes 4,5,6, and now 7. I thought I made that quite clear. As for the prequel stuff, I haven't got a clue what your talking about nor what they are actually about, all I know is that the prequels are universally panned, I plan on watching them soon to make my own opinion but till then I will reserve judgement. If what you described is true, well I guess I can see why the prequels were bad.  Also what you described sounds so much like Dragon ballz where no matter how hard Vegeta trained all Goku had to do is fart once and he'll auto levels past Vegeta, stupid shit like this makes these characters unrelatable, it's why Superman movies are hard to do, how do you make a character relatable if it's a god and can't be defeated, this is why people like Batman more than Superman, cuz you know one is a mere human while the other a god, and if they do this with Star wars episode 8 then I'm gonna start rooting for Kylo cuz he would be the underdog. If the writters were aiming to make me root for Rey but they god mode her and end up making me root for Kylo, then they fucked up, just saying.



jake_the_fake1 said:
WolfpackN64 said:

What? If you felt "gender representation was forced" you must have been looking for it the entire movie.

This is a load of BS.



 

Looking for it no,  it was just blatantly obvious, the forced part is in reference to each scene have 50/50. Don't know how you could of missed it since it's right their in your face, but hey some people can be oblivious to certain things, it's only natural. But if you don't believe then, or think I'm talking BS, then I compel you to go see the movie again, I'm pretty certain you'll see what I'm talking about even if you admit or not.

I guess I may have just given you then excuse to do see this movie again, i would like your opinion on you second watch.



I just enjoyed the movie. Looking back at it, it had a good representation, but how is this a bad thing. You're the first person I've seen complaining about it.





WolfpackN64 said:
jake_the_fake1 said:

 

Looking for it no,  it was just blatantly obvious, the forced part is in reference to each scene have 50/50. Don't know how you could of missed it since it's right their in your face, but hey some people can be oblivious to certain things, it's only natural. But if you don't believe then, or think I'm talking BS, then I compel you to go see the movie again, I'm pretty certain you'll see what I'm talking about even if you admit or not.

I guess I may have just given you then excuse to do see this movie again, i would like your opinion on you second watch.



I just enjoyed the movie. Looking back at it, it had a good representation, but how is this a bad thing. You're the first person I've seen complaining about it.



I don't have issues with representation per se, and no I was not complaining, I was merely pointing out what I saw as odd. Having 50/50 representation in every scene just struck me as and foced, I mean it's an intergalactic war, surely there would have been more aliens mixed in, and if that were the case I'd probably never noticed it. But hey if their happened to be a clown in one of the scenes, some would see it and point it out, and others would have missed it all together, it's just that type of thing.



As I said in the other thread, good movie, but left me with a bleak taste.

 

Nice new protagonists, dull villain, awesome BB-8, great sequences and nice musical score, but way too many questionable plot designs, plot devices and incongruences. Feels like J.J. lost himself to his Star Wars nerdy side at a certain point and borrowed way too much from previous movies without ever giving proper context. 



Saw it! I freakin' loved it