Quantcast
Biggest city in a game?

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Biggest city in a game?

Biggest city in a game?

Liberty City (GTA IV) 11 9.40%
 
Rome (AC: Brotherhood) 8 6.84%
 
Hong Kong (Sleeping Dogs) 3 2.56%
 
Chicago (Watch Dogs) 3 2.56%
 
Los Santos (GTA V) 54 46.15%
 
Hong Kong (Sleeping Dogs) 1 0.85%
 
Other 37 31.62%
 
Total:117

Kakariko Village, The Legend of Zelda: OoT



psn- tokila

add me, the more the merrier.

Around the Network
SvennoJ said:
AG80 said:
 

I don't agree with your accuracy of scaling these images. For one thing I'm sure that LC in GTA IV is a lot bigger than LS in GTA: SA, not just a little big bigger. And then you have Alderney also in GTA IV's map. I can also prove it here - you can clearly see the roads marked on GTA: SA while they are barely visible in GTA IV's map which suggests that GTA IV's map is zoomed out compared to GTA: SA.

I didn't scale them, but it seems to be the general consensus on the gta forums, many more pics show the same comparison between GTA 4 and SA




GTA 4 was a more densely packed city though.

So what I get from this pic is that the Broker/Dukes island itself is nearly 4/5th as big as Los Santos besides obviously being a lot more dense. That's some interesting stuff. Thanks for these pics!



tokilamockingbrd said:
Kakariko Village, The Legend of Zelda: OoT

Joke post? There are many, many cities in games that are much bigger than it. Hell even some of GTA IV's big districts (not even islands) are bigger than that.



AG80 said:

So what I get from this pic is that the Broker/Dukes island itself is nearly 4/5th as big as Los Santos besides obviously being a lot more dense. That's some interesting stuff. Thanks for these pics!

GTA IV felt like a real city to me, same as LA Noir. In other games it feels like a scale model of a city. Except some of the AC cities, they felt pretty real too. GTA IV was annoying with the maintaining friends thing, yet now I'm playing GTA V I'm actually getting more respect for GTA IV. 5 tries to capture the magic of San Andreas but falls short. It's still a lot of fun anyway. San Andreas remains king for me.

Is it a coincidence that the more realistic the city, the more dull the gameplay becomes :/



GTA SA?



Around the Network

Mute City (F-Zero) with its population of 200+ million people
http://fzero.wikia.com/wiki/Mute_City

ok, that was lame....you can´t explore Mute City. :P



AG80 said:
tokilamockingbrd said:
Kakariko Village, The Legend of Zelda: OoT

Joke post? There are many, many cities in games that are much bigger than it. Hell even some of GTA IV's big districts (not even islands) are bigger than that.


wait you never found the house in the Village that opens up into a massive underworld city occupied by Dwaves and Wizards? Its huge.



psn- tokila

add me, the more the merrier.

Liberty City in GTA IV is a lot smaller than GTA V map. It fits in the Los Santos area.



SvennoJ said:
AG80 said:
 

So what I get from this pic is that the Broker/Dukes island itself is nearly 4/5th as big as Los Santos besides obviously being a lot more dense. That's some interesting stuff. Thanks for these pics!

GTA IV felt like a real city to me, same as LA Noir. In other games it feels like a scale model of a city. Except some of the AC cities, they felt pretty real too. GTA IV was annoying with the maintaining friends thing, yet now I'm playing GTA V I'm actually getting more respect for GTA IV. 5 tries to capture the magic of San Andreas but falls short. It's still a lot of fun anyway. San Andreas remains king for me.

Is it a coincidence that the more realistic the city, the more dull the gameplay becomes :/

Maintaining friends is just an optional task, you can skip it completely (I didn't though) but its cool for those that like to see characters outside story missions, and a cool way to discover new interiors in the map.



AG80 said:
Marks said:
Los Santos is like 5x bigger than Liberty City lol.

That's San Andreas you're talking about, I'm just counting cities here, not entire states.


Fair enough. No idea then. Haven't played many open world games besides Rockstar's ones.