COD4, fallout 3, mass effect, gta4.

Yeah ok.. I agree with you. Super Mario Land 2 was brilliant too.. 

Friend of mine made me play a FIFA game on his X1. God, I dunno the appeal of it at all XD

Destiny was meh, but with the realization of all the locked DLC content that was in the alpha build it's more like "sign me up for any class action lawsuit".  The community manager DeeJ even claimed the alpha build was "ancient" so who knows how long areas like the Seraphim Vault, Jovian Complex, and King's Watch were finished. They were fully rendered and the final version of DLC 1 content only includes enemies that are in the base game. All they had to do was plop down scripted spawn locations for the enemies and hire a voice actor. Clearly it seems this was all cut content shown to our face months before release and a "meh" doesn't fit that description.

Back on topic:

Minecraft, Halo Reach, Titanfall, MGS2, Twilight Princess, The Nintendo Wii in general lol

>>Halo 4 was the biggest disappointment for me ever in gaming though. 

Four Swords Adventure, probably the worst Zelda game

Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced 2
Super Mario Land(although it was alright for its time)
Arc Rise Fantasia
Tales of the Abyss
Legend of Dragoon
Assassin's Creed
Golden Sun: Dark Dawn
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze

Indeed.

The first Assassin's Creed, Mario 3D Land, several of the Tales game (graces in particular), the entire Fable series.

Thats not what he is asking for.

Every game is not as good as it could have been. TLoU on PS3 can have 30 fps or 60 instead of 18-30.
Mario Kart8 could have 1080p 60 instead of 720p 59.
etc etc etc.

btw strange taste you have.




For me the correct answer would probably be "insert random third party game here".

Most third party games are pure mediocrity.

or "insert random game here that favors visuals over gameplay"  its good looking and meh. and in a few years its meh looking and meh. A few years later its bad looking and meh. 

If gameplay is good the game stays good no matter how much time passes.

Medal of Honor reboot (The first one). The second one was garbage on the other hand.