By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - GTA V PS4 vs Xbox One 1080p Video and Screenshot Comparison: Xbox One Version Sightly More Detailed

GribbleGrunger said:
Landguy said:
Another day, another comparison thread!

Well, might as well join in the fun.

This is just another opinion piece. Just like DF is. There isn't ever going to be a definitive source for an answer. If you are a PS fan, you find every little detail that wouldn't be found if you were PLAYING the game and try to create a justification of the vaunted "50% more power". If your an XB1 fan, you dismiss the mostly obvious minor detail differences as just that and say "gameplay is what matters". Neither side wins.

So, while some people are counting bushes in screenshots and others are playing the game, we can all wonder who is getting more out of this?!

You don't think you're biased?

Yes, that's the whole point I was making.

But, you pointed out that I admitted that their are "mostly obvious" differences.  As usual, a person who may be obsessed with being a console warrior will not grasp that nobody is arguing that there are different versions of the game much anymore.  People have moved on to debating how much ther differences really add up to or what is really causing them.

This cycle gets repeated with almost every multi-platform title.  There is a large argument between the fans of either system about which version is better graphically(usually the PS4 for obvious reasons).  The argument goes through multiple version in the multiple threads as people accept that the PS4 is usually better in some minute way.  Then everyone debates how that it could have been more or less if the developer had tried harder.  And then the debate goes to the techies arguing over the technical reasons behind the differences.  Luck for us all, there is usually another game that comes out shortly after to start the debae again.

So, if people just accepted that the XB1 version will usaully have minor differences/deficiances than the PS4 version, they could spend a whole lot more of their time playing games.  Of course, that would require people to also accept that in almost all of the cases the actual gampelay difference is very little if any.  That seems to be the hard part for people to get over.



It is near the end of the end....

Around the Network
GribbleGrunger said:
walsufnir said:


This sums it up quite good. There is really nothing important about grass in this case. And it wasn't ever, like last gen when it was missing in RDR or other games.

It is just to rub in others noses which is arguebly a sign of maturity.

I'm sorry, but people can't keep saying things like this in a thread that's suggesting the XB1 version is best using cutscenes with questionable quality. Missing assets are missing assets, even in 520p. Even if it turns out to be pop in, that's BAD pop in. Or did you and others think you could have this thread all to yourselves?

This isn't about 'beating' anyone, it's about qualifying a lie.


Of course they can. You can't forbid people having perhaps stupid or uneducated or biased opinions and making posts or threads influenced by this. The question is how you respond to such posts as a person. Look how ethomaz didn't even reply to me when I told him that DF's video has no crushed blacks, leaving him without the ability to respond when he before claimed many times crushed blacks.

Either way, if a difference is small or big seems also to be a question of personal preference and buying decision justification where I am out as I didn't even enter next-gen.

Relax and have a nice day :)



Landguy said:

Yes, that's the whole point I was making.

But, you pointed out that I admitted that their are "mostly obvious" differences.  As usual, a person who may be obsessed with being a console warrior will not grasp that nobody is arguing that there are different versions of the game much anymore.  People have moved on to debating how much ther differences really add up to or what is really causing them.

This cycle gets repeated with almost every multi-platform title.  There is a large argument between the fans of either system about which version is better graphically(usually the PS4 for obvious reasons).  The argument goes through multiple version in the multiple threads as people accept that the PS4 is usually better in some minute way.  Then everyone debates how that it could have been more or less if the developer had tried harder.  And then the debate goes to the techies arguing over the technical reasons behind the differences.  Luck for us all, there is usually another game that comes out shortly after to start the debae again.

So, if people just accepted that the XB1 version will usaully have minor differences/deficiances than the PS4 version, they could spend a whole lot more of their time playing games.  Of course, that would require people to also accept that in almost all of the cases the actual gampelay difference is very little if any.  That seems to be the hard part for people to get over.

Well, this I can agree with. It's just that your wording appeared to reveal something ... maybe I was mistaken or you could have worded that better (I don't know)

The XB1 version will be excellent and play very well.



 

The PS5 Exists. 


Zekkyou said:
Landguy said:
Another day, another comparison thread!

Well, might as well join in the fun.

This is just another opinion piece. Just like DF is. There isn't ever going to be a definitive source for an answer. If you are a PS fan, you find every little detail that wouldn't be found if you were PLAYING the game and try to create a justification of the vaunted "50% more power". If your an XB1 fan, you dismiss the mostly obvious minor detail differences as just that and say "gameplay is what matters". Neither side wins.

So, while some people are counting bushes in screenshots and others are playing the game, we can all wonder who is getting more out of this?!

So you're criticizing people for acting on their biases by lettings yours influence your wording? ^^

Not sure of the bias so much.  I have yet to see in ANY of these debates prove that there is an overwhelming difference.  I find that a person can't even try and stay middle of the road(which these bolded comments prove) without one side or the other trying to find nuances in the words to try andd make a point.  Just like the minor detail differences in the games, people try to disect every word for some greater hidden meaning.  I am not saying that we all don't have some type of bias, but I believe that it isn't always as black and white as some hope it to be.



It is near the end of the end....

Landguy said:

Not sure of the bias so much.  I have yet to see in ANY of these debates prove that there is an overwhelming difference.  I find that a person can't even try and stay middle of the road(which these bolded comments prove) without one side or the other trying to find nuances in the words to try andd make a point.  Just like the minor detail differences in the games, people try to disect every word for some greater hidden meaning.  I am not saying that we all don't have some type of bias, but I believe that it isn't always as black and white as some hope it to be.

Not sure what that has to do with what i said. You made a comment saying [x] does [y] and [a] does , and you wrote it in the exact fashion you said [a] would. I found it somewhat amusing.



Around the Network
bubblegamer said:
The PS4 version looks better from what i can see. X1 still has issues with the crushed black it seems. The contrast is too dark.


I don't think there are any crushed blacks in the xbox one version.  Everything is pretty washed out compared to the colours of last gen.



walsufnir said:
Cobretti2 said:
SweetTalia said:

lol nah. doubt it

well im not exactly standing still now am I?

GTA is about the auction and not admiring the decor.

 


You are wrong, it's about the grass!


I guess I never noticed the grass cause its so blury on PS3 that is is almost non existant. Yep that grass sure does add t the atmosphere.

In all seriousness the only cool with with the new version of the game is the FPS mode and FPS mode sex with a hooker. I am yet to get the game but with outraged parents already they may block that out lol.



 

 

Cobretti2 said:
walsufnir said:
Cobretti2 said:
SweetTalia said:

lol nah. doubt it

well im not exactly standing still now am I?

GTA is about the auction and not admiring the decor.

 


You are wrong, it's about the grass!


I guess I never noticed the grass cause its so blury on PS3 that is is almost non existant. Yep that grass sure does add t the atmosphere.

In all seriousness the only cool with with the new version of the game is the FPS mode and FPS mode sex with a hooker. I am yet to get the game but with outraged parents already they may block that out lol.


texture assets seem to be higher too if you care about that.