By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

theprof00 said:
impertinence said:

Yeah, well. Really worring that your reasoning for not claiming is to give yourself a challenge. It comes across as putting yourself ahead of the interest of town. Especially since your claim raises some legitimate concerns, and you felt you needed to lie about it.

Nice chainsaw. Responding to a line of reasoning with undermining my playstyle.

I'm not about to play the claim game yet, especially when you yourself said that there is no reason for people to claim without pressure.

Well, as you know I think you've been effectivly counterclaimed and the made up name for your ability doesn't fit with the terran flavor. If that is not enough pressure for you then by all means, enjoy your extra challenge. I am just pointing out how it looks to me.

Also, don't think I didn't notice how you turned questions about your claim into trying to pin me on knowing the status of a Dark Templar and when the conversation turns back to where we started you claim chainsaw defence. Seems like you're just throwing stuff at the wall now and see if anything sticks. Was I right when I suggested you're running out of places to hide?



Around the Network
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

Today I'll be your yes man, I feel exactly the same way, only not that he is protoss. I think he is a zerg detector of some sort.



TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.


Wouldn't you say that padibs claim of being an infected terran is a pretty good indication that there are zerg in the game?



impertinence said:
Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.


Wouldn't you say that padibs claim of being an infected terran is a pretty good indication that there are zerg in the game?

I don't know a damn thing about starcraft flavor.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Around the Network
Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.

Why do you think so?



impertinence said:
Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.

Wouldn't you say that padibs claim of being an infected terran is a pretty good indication that there are zerg in the game?

But padib claims to be town. Do you think he's zerg?

Also

"Also, don't think I didn't notice how you turned questions about your claim into trying to pin me on knowing the status of a Dark Templar and when the conversation turns back to where we started you claim chainsaw defence."

That was actually you just rolefishing. We also have the claimed shield marine without a name. Your line of investigation didn't fit any established logic, and then said things I was saying were odd when you had no reason to think so.



It goes.
Prof claims.
Prof asks Trucks how he'd know wright has a name.
Impertinence says it's odd that prof wouldn't have a name despite having an ability. (AGain, shield marine WEPL with no claimed name. Not odd)
Prof says he never said he didn't have a name, he just didn't assume that players had names.
Imp says that statement is odd as well, since we have 4 vanilla flips with no names. (logic doesn't follow how that's odd)
Prof asks why Imp knows DT is vanilla mafia role.
Imp says he used wiki, and that DTs are just a protoss tribe with no role.
Prof says DTs are invisible in Starcraft. So, they do in fact have a role.
Imp says wiki resource must be incorrect. 2 ninjas seems overpowered.
Prof says it depends on the game setup. Odd that Imp hasn't considered the setup given the information available.
Imp pushes implications about prof lying about the role name having some bearing on a scum-alignment, and non-team playstyle. (Remind anyone of last game with hylian? "You're a threat to town as either town or scum")
Prof calls out the chainsaw.
Imp says that he was the one starting with the questioning.

Quesitoning, as I've shown, was not only fruitless, but illogical.



theprof00 said:
Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.

Why do you think so?

Under the theory that the ghost can murder at Night.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

theprof00 said:
impertinence said:
Mr Khan said:
TruckOSaurus said:
My feeling is that prof is either Zerg or Protoss but isn't lying about his ability. He's helping town with the hunt for the Ghost since scum also loses if they get blown to bits.

But prof's voted out the last two Protoss. I don't think Zerg are around, either.

Wouldn't you say that padibs claim of being an infected terran is a pretty good indication that there are zerg in the game?

But padib claims to be town. Do you think he's zerg?

Also

"Also, don't think I didn't notice how you turned questions about your claim into trying to pin me on knowing the status of a Dark Templar and when the conversation turns back to where we started you claim chainsaw defence."

That was actually you just rolefishing. We also have the claimed shield marine without a name. Your line of investigation didn't fit any established logic, and then said things I was saying were odd when you had no reason to think so.


I've already stated how I feel about Padib's status as infected terran, but I guess you don't pay much attention to the thread as established earlier today?

Anyway, how could I possibly be rolefishing when you already had claimed your role? Your claim and the subsequent counter claim made you stand out like a sore thumb, I have not been rolefishing for one second. I've asked you to give the name of your character/unit/ whatever it might be. But you won't, because you like the challenge. Or for what I think the real reason is: you don;t wnat to have to make up a terran name/character and risk getting counter claimed.

For someone who frequently likes to take shots at other players use of logic you might want to take at your own play right now.