I felt the exact same way, and still do to this day.  Dual analog sticks made fps games sort of almost bearable to play on consoles, but when you're used to a keyboard and mouse everything just pales in comparison for an fps.

I'd say the best Nintendo DS game deserves to be in this list.

TLoU? Really? It has completely retarded AI. I doubt it even deserves top 10.

Where's Final Fantasy XIII?

Shenmue at #7? lol ok I wont take this list seriously. It's not a bad game but being the 7th best game of all time? lol

I tried replaying it a year or so ago and I really didn't have too much fun! The game deserves props for what it did back in the day though!

I kind of agree. Maybe not 5 years old, but I wouldn't think anything released later than 2012 is old enough to be viewed very objectively. Such games would also be too young for us to see if they're going to become truly influential, like Ocarina of Time or Mario 64 have been.

TLoU in particular received an insane amount of hype for being "cinematic". While I imagine the game will still be highly regarded a few years from now, I suspect there'll be less people frothing at the mouth over it. I certainly don't expect it to rank #1 on a whole ton of best-of lists in five years.

Here's a better list compiled by a gaming website as opposed to a film publication: http://www.gamerankings.com/browse.html

Of note is Uncharted 2 being above TLoU as it should be! Also GTA SA should be above the more recent GTAs IMO. Sucks RE4 Wii did not make it on the list though! The wiimote worked great in that game!

The Last of Us being #1 makes sense.

Not above Uncharted 2: U2 had better writing.