Brawl.
Bite me.

All-stars....I kid I kid.

I've played Brawl the must so my vote goes to it.

I prefer brawl.I never got a chance to play melee :(

Brawl was a disappointment compared to Melee.

And god help you if you were trying to play it with the Wiimote.

Melee played the best out of any of them, for sure. And it has the best intro ever. (; Among my friends was really fun. Brawl was good. I think I did get more playtime out of it, and I do love the range of stages, characters, and far vaster music collection etc. It looked a bit better, too, easier on the eyes now a bit.
So all that considered I'm gonna have to go wiiiith...

Project M

Dat poll

I've always liked Brawl better.

I liked Brawl's characters, stages, and gameplay modes better. Actual gameplay-wise, they were about the same for me. I hear competitive players prefer Melee for that aspect, but I only played locally with friends and family, and it still rocked in that regard.

Though to be fair, the addition of my favorite Fire Emblem hero would have influenced my vote regardless of anything else at play. XD

For me it's:

SSB>SSBM>>>>>>>>>>SSBB

I think the gameplay was best in SSB, even though it was missing a lot of features that came later.
SSBB was a major letdown for me. It felt so slow and floaty.

That's really difficult...If we're talking about for it's time then the first one is really tough to beat because of just how awesome it was...But Brawl did a lot to expand the series...but if I could only play one of them for the rest of my life I'd probably choose Melee...