By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - Do you think that Socialism could ever get a strong foothold in the USA? (read op)

 

Do you think that a Socialist party could ever become a leading party in the USA?

Yes 38 29.23%
 
Maybe/Don't know 26 20.00%
 
No 64 49.23%
 
Total:128
generic-user-1 said:
hm if europe is socialist, socialism won... detroit looks like the set of mad max, even the poorest parts of europe are way more safe. u can have holidays in greece without fear. try the same in detroit...

Not sure why you'd use crime to crituqe an economic system.


In Detroit the Median income is ~$25,000.

In Greece it's ~$15,000.



Around the Network
NobleTeam360 said:
Yeah their* called Democrats.

*They're

Not today's Democrats. In most other democracies 75% of the Democrats in congress, and Obama himself would be considered right-of-centre.

That people think mandated health insurance is socialism running roughshod on 'Murican freedoms shows how far right the USA as a nation has gone.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

Kasz216 said:
generic-user-1 said:
hm if europe is socialist, socialism won... detroit looks like the set of mad max, even the poorest parts of europe are way more safe. u can have holidays in greece without fear. try the same in detroit...

Not sure why you'd use crime to crituqe an economic system.


In Detroit the Median income is ~$25,000.

In Greece it's ~$15,000.

well the most people care more about not beeing shot for chickenwings than about 10.000$ more a year...

and u dont think the total breakdown in detroit has something to do with the economic system?  or are poor people from greece just nicer than poor americans?



binary solo said:
NobleTeam360 said:
Yeah their* called Democrats.

*They're

Not today's Democrats. In most other democracies 75% of the Democrats in congress, and Obama himself would be considered right-of-centre.

That people think mandated health insurance is socialism running roughshod on 'Murican freedoms shows how far right the USA as a nation has gone.

 

Not really no.

I mean, have you compaired the US response to the GFC compaired to the Europeon one?

If your talking more then just economically, I can list about a dozen ways the UK, Germany or France for example are socially conservative compaired to the US mainstream.  Espiecally with the rise of "Blue Labour" who brilliantly think the reason they lost the elections is because they don't hate immigrants enough.

Ever look at Europeon Abortion laws?  When it comes to just ease of access and amount of time to get it done... the US is pretty hard to beat.  Heavy restrictions usually coming down in the 1st trimester in most cases... often with hoops to jump through.  US, you just make an apointment.

But the parameters seem to be economic so it's better to start there.



generic-user-1 said:
Kasz216 said:
generic-user-1 said:
hm if europe is socialist, socialism won... detroit looks like the set of mad max, even the poorest parts of europe are way more safe. u can have holidays in greece without fear. try the same in detroit...

Not sure why you'd use crime to crituqe an economic system.


In Detroit the Median income is ~$25,000.

In Greece it's ~$15,000.

well the most people care more about not beeing shot for chickenwings than about 10.000$ more a year...

and u dont think the total breakdown in detroit has something to do with the economic system?  or are poor people from greece just nicer than poor americans?

 

Nicer?  No.  Less Violent.  Yes.

Detroit doesn't have NEARLY the food security problems Greece does.

Culture is a factor in crime afterall.

 

Also... total Breakdown in detroit?   That's pretty hyperbolic.

 

 

It peaked in 2012, and is headed downwards again, 47% in 2007, even though they've made more police cutbacks and the economy is worse there.



Around the Network

Probably never.. too much paranoia and misconceptions about what it actually is.



If it isn't turnbased it isn't worth playing   (mostly)

And shepherds we shall be,

For Thee, my Lord, for Thee. Power hath descended forth from Thy hand, That our feet may swiftly carry out Thy command. So we shall flow a river forth to Thee And teeming with souls shall it ever be. In Nomine Patris, et Filii, et Spiritūs Sancti. -----The Boondock Saints

Kasz216 said:
generic-user-1 said:
Kasz216 said:
generic-user-1 said:
hm if europe is socialist, socialism won... detroit looks like the set of mad max, even the poorest parts of europe are way more safe. u can have holidays in greece without fear. try the same in detroit...

Not sure why you'd use crime to crituqe an economic system.


In Detroit the Median income is ~$25,000.

In Greece it's ~$15,000.

well the most people care more about not beeing shot for chickenwings than about 10.000$ more a year...

and u dont think the total breakdown in detroit has something to do with the economic system?  or are poor people from greece just nicer than poor americans?

 

Nicer?  No.  Less Violent.  Yes.

Detroit doesn't have NEARLY the food security problems Greece does.

Culture is a factor in crime afterall.

 

Also... total Breakdown in detroit?   That's pretty hyperbolic.

 

 

It peaked in 2012, and is headed downwards again, 47% in 2007, even though they've made more police cutbacks and the economy is worse there.

dude those numbers are realy realy terrible... i life the biggest state of germany, 17-18million inhabitants and something around 100 Murder

thats way less than  half the murders of detroid, a town with 600.000 inhabitants...



binary solo said:
NobleTeam360 said:
Yeah their* called Democrats.

*They're

Not today's Democrats. In most other democracies 75% of the Democrats in congress, and Obama himself would be considered right-of-centre.

That people think mandated health insurance is socialism running roughshod on 'Murican freedoms shows how far right the USA as a nation has gone.

Thank you professor. 



generic-user-1 said:

dude those numbers are realy realy terrible... i life the biggest state of germany, 17-18million inhabitants and something around 100 Murder

thats way less than  half the murders of detroid, a town with 600.000 inhabitants...

Well first off... that's murder rate.  Not actual murder numbers.  

Secondly, murder rates for major cities are going to be higher then murder rates for states.   The Equivlent to your German State is actually included on that graph.  It would be that Red line listed Michigan.   Which is the State that Detroit is in.

Thirdly, the numbers are terrible... but consistantly terrible.

In otherwords, there hasn't been a "Total breakdown" in Detroit due to the tanking economy.



ToxicJosh said:

Traditionally speaking there are 3 views on human nature: good, bad, and neutral. Conservatives tend to feel more negatively about people, liberals more positive and people who think about it realise that there are some good and some bad, and that people are probably born as a blank slate, or tabula rasa, and that how they are raised probably plays a great deal into whether or not they turn into saints or scumbags. (Notice how none of that carries any relevance to economic theories?)

Personally, I think that all that human nature tells us is what the actual nature of the person holding that view is: as the only mind we get to see inside is our own. So someone who says that people are inherently lazy, selfish and only out for themselves is, in all likelihood, lazy, selfish and only out for themselves. People who think that people are naturally loving and kind are probably going to be loving and kind.

The only way this plays into economic theories is that people who are greedy want to able to accumulate wealth; and therefore are more likely to want a system that enables them to do so (capitalism). People who consider everyone to be equal, are more likely to want a system that removes wealth from private hands (socialism).

But really, that's stretching credulity in terms of a criticism of socialism. Sorry for the rant.

Rubbish. What a self rightgeous view of yourself and this is evident in shaping your views.

"(Notice how none of that carries any relevance to economic theories?)"

Ofcourse it does, and is at the heart of Game Theory which has shaped modern economics.

If you have a system that doesn't account for lazy people even if only some of them are and it then doesn't take steps to stop them being lazy then they're able to "game the system" and get other people to pay for what they want/need: children, healthcare, living expenses etc.

I agree with you that capitalism doesn't take steps to prevent greed by the most capable but the above must be recognised equally rather than simply glossing over with some rubbish that people who think like this are probably just lazy and selfish themselves.

Personally I'm a right-wing leaning liberal democrat, essentially the government we have in the UK at the moment (I actually got exactly what I wanted) because I think that form of government gives a good balance between the two. Socialism however in it's purest form, like communism simply doesn't work. Capitalism equally eventually fails like we've seen although I also want to point out that pure Capitalism hasn't been tried, in a Capitalist society banks wouldn't have been bailed out or would even have needed to be as it wouldn't use a fiat currency which essentially lead to all the debt. However I'm under no doubt that pure Capitalism would eventually lead to monopolies or cabals that would ultimately have absolute power over the citizens and a reduction in growth and an increase in social inequality.