starworld said:
well thats a very unfair comparison, since graphics have advanced so much, no so much becuase of the hardware, but because of new techniques/engines, especially in lighting, and then your comparing sony's lowest budget titles/teams to nintendo best, compare those 3d mario to GOW3 both linear games, god of war stumps it, as for baynetta it was platnums first game on 360, it was like 5 years ago, they easily be able to makr a better looking game then first since they have way more experiance now, not to mention DMC4 looks so much better then bayonetta.
I agree with you when comes to new techniques and games engines being developed on the same hardware as time passes because efficiency in utilization of the hardware increases yet when comes to utilization of the hardware we can obviously see who has the edge also claiming that comparison is rather unfair is a stretch... What you are doing is unfair and denying it means that you have double standards...
Xbox 360 is Microsofts and PlayStation 3 is Sony's first high definition home console and Wii U is for Nintendo first also.
White Knight Chronicles's is Level 5's(with help from SCE Japan) first HD game and same is valid for X that is Monolith Soft's first HD game and both studios didn't had any previous experience into HD development. WKC is not a low budget game except if you are comparing to triple A budget games of today or to be more specifics, standards nowadays. Level 5 and Monolith Soft are on the same level now in prominence/reputation. Second screen was from White Knight Chronicles 2 and not the first one/original, it looks better than original yet it does not look near as good as Monolith Soft's X and Level 5 by then had 3-4+ years of experience in HD development also they get help from SCE Japan.
Also your comparison of Super Mario 3D World with God Of War 3 is extremely fair because they aren't in the same genre and I compared games that are in same genre, you are comparing a platformer with a hack n slash game. I might as well compare Little Big Planet Kart with Forza games on Xbox 360 that is simulation racer rather than with Mario Kart 8 which is a kart racer/in the same genre and sub category. Your comparison is like comparing apples with oranges which is an epic/utter failure...
Here is screenshots from around the net of Bayonetta 2, God Of War 3, Devil May Cry 4 and single screenshot of Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance also Bayonetta 2 screenshots are either taken from youtube video of Nintendo Direct or directly from its stream or from Platinum Games 60 FPS videos. I tried to find most comparable situations and settings/set up;
As you can see... Bayonetta 2 is superior in detail in comparison to God Of War 3, Devil May Cry 4 and Metal Gear Rising Revengeance that is made by Platinum Games. I looked for comparable shots, like settings, size of bosses and number or enemies and also that screenshots are not bullshots.
as for Knight Chronicles(PS3) and Monolith Soft's X. you can clearly see they are close knight chronicls seems to have better AA, and X better lighting, but as i mentioned before lighting engines have advanced so much since KC came out.
Screens of Monolith Soft's X are taken from youtube video of Nintendo Direct or directly from Nintendo Direct's stream thus there screens suffer from compression which lowers quality of picture considerably and I tried to find screens that suffer the least from these compression versus screens of White Knight Chronicles that are taken directly from the console/hardware/in-game compared to presented screens of Monolith Soft's X which is not.
|