Actually due to the holiday digital bundle that Reach received in 2011 it's probably about tied for sales with GT5. If I remember my calculations right it roughly sold 1.1 million in digital copies during the time that it was bundled and that doesn't include the other 2 or so years it's been on demand (which is increasingly becoming a bigger market on the 360). So best bet is to add a couple hundred thousand onto that. Overall I would estimate Reach at around 10.6 million (taking the very low end of sales)

Either way though one game didn't meet my sales expectation (Reach) whilst the other one (GT5) genuinely surprised me. Congrats to GT5 for being the first PS3 exclusive to cross 10 million.

Yes, time-limited bundles.

GT5 (which I found instantly via google pics):

The first demo that got sold... No, it was sold separately and should of course be counted as a separate game. Tell me why VGC counts both games separately. You are free to discuss this with ioi.

Oh so everything that was in halo 3 was in halo 3 odst?  just like everything that was in gt5 prologue was in gt5?

Guys...I gotta point out that both Reach and GT5 were bundled quite extensively. So it's a wash in that aspect really.

4 Halo's this gen v 1 GT............. was bound to pass some of them.

Halo 3 will hold on though.

Seeing as you counted the limited GT5 bundle, allow me to also count a couple of Halo limited bundles.

Deyon said: walsufnir said: Yes, time-limited bundles. GT5 (which I found instantly via google pics): Seeing as you counted the limited GT5 ps3 bundle, allow me to also count a couple of Halo limited console bundles

Sure you are allowed to do that but the comparison is still in favor of halo :) But yes, there were also many time-limited halo-bundles.

Halo reach is around 11m you forget digita sales

Wasn't Halo Reach and Fable 3 bundled for like two years?