one was almost for sure before the first guy voted, journey will win and halo or mario will be second. too many guys who would only vote for the most important exclusive even if they wouldn't be also the best.

Journey, for its art, for being non-violent and for telling its story through unique, non-cinematic way - but most of all for being THE game that shows how vastly different games could be than what mainstream offers and yet as immersive, and both critically and commercially successful.

Xenoblade? Kid Icarus? KH 3d?

Halo4

Sleeping Dogs, Dishonored I guess out of the list but not voting for my 2nd favorite game of the year.

My personal choice: Journey.

Unique, emotive and incredibly satisfying... there is no other choice this year.

Is this list genuine?

Borderlands 2 is my GOTY.

lmao Playstation allstars on the list.....a game that has a metacritic of 76 and has sold poorly on the list.....What is even more shocking is it has 4 votes :P

Sonic Allstars and New Super Mario Bros U is pretty bad choices too.

It's not on the list but my choice is Resident Evil 6.