Update: I have decided to give 800 MS points or a $10 PSN card (sorry Wii only users, I don't know how to get you guys anything) every 3 months to the person who I feel has consistantly had the best reviews in my threads. Hopefully this will inspire even more great reviews in these threads. Your reviews start to count on April 29th 2011 so the person with the best reviews will win at the end of July.

All you have to do is put what score you think the game below deserves, and write a brief explanation as to why it deserves that score.

Voting is open for 3 days, after the 3 day period I will count up all the scores and get the average of the game.  I will be putting up a new thread with a new game every 3 days

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rules

1. You had to have played at least enough of the game to form an honest opinion about it

(playing it for 5 minutes is NOT enough time, nor is watching a friend play the game)

2. Scores have to be on a 10 point scale with 7 being average.

3. If you score a game 5 or under, you have to go into great detail as to why you gave it such a low score.

4. A game must have at least 15 people that gave it a score to be counted.

5. If you score a game more than once none of your scores will count

6. Users with less than 50 posts cannot score a game.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Last game was Red Dead Redemption with a score of 8.20

Highest score was 10, lowest was 2

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vgchartz score -- 8.73

GamrReview score -- 8.7

Highest score was 10, lowest was 4

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vgchartz top 12 rated games

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

   Next game is Alan Wake

7

Pros- It's fun, I liked the case, it's increased in price since I bought it

Cons- Felt cheap at times, annoying color scheme, not that difficult, couldn't live up to the hype 

Sorry, I'm actually good at games >:P 

Demon's Souls - 9.6 (I LOVE IT)

Good

- The new and revolucionary online multiplayer;
- The amazing tendency system;
- The big boss battles;
- The atmosphere and environment;
- The addictive gameplay and level system;
- The NPCs;
- The challenge thing;
- The New Game plus system;
- The replay value (for me over 100 hours);
- All other stuffs;
- The best RPG (or JRPG) this gen;

Bad

- A little short;
- No Demon's Souls 2 yet;
- Nothing more;

0_o

Pro's

- Good challenge

- Amazing intro video

- Great co-op system

- Great enemy design

- Engaging story

- Deep atmosphere

Con's

- I disliked the lack of tutorial especially when it came to the equipment system. Very confusing.

- The menus are very messy

- Clunky control scheme

I thus give it 8.7/10

Lol I haven't actually played it but I watched my cousin attempt many times to beat the first mission where your in ghost form (he never did beat it)

It looks sickeningly hard!

The first level is the easiest! I only died once on it, and that was when I tried to fight that guy with the long spear on top of the wall. >__> 

Bastard... 

I don't even know what to say about this insanity lol.

Unfortunatly I haven't played Demons Souls yet so I can't vote, but I do plan on picking it up sometime over the summer and beating it.

Though I do already have Dark Souls pre-ordered without ever playing the original Demons Souls haha