VGC Mafia Round 24

[c03n3nj0]

hatmoza said:

Linkzmax said:

c03n3nj0 said:

hatmoza said:

Yes, true.

Who did prof suspect btw? Wasn't MG one of them? If yes, it could be that he actually happened to finger more than one mafia player, giving us a better range of lynch candidates.

If either Vette or ST where on his list, that would even further pin-point a target making this day a lot easier than we anticipated.

Nope, prof didn't suspect MG, at least in not int he same list as Trucks, Sak, stefl and I:  http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3827353

Nor in his summary: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3828407 
While doing the 'MG at a glance' above I don't recall anything from prof about him outside of calling him out early day one for one-liners, mentioning him as far as contributions around the time he posted the potals, and noting that Truck hasn't had any conversation with MG.

hat, how would Vette/ST being on prof's(I assume?) list make today any easier? Since they were modkilled I don't really see much we can gain from their suspicions, though it's possible there's information in who was actually onto them. dtewi/Kantor voted ST day one. Truck and nen(and scottie) voted for ST day two though later unvoted.(though neither voted for scottie either) Vette never received a single vote. I'd obviously have to check back to see if there were any FoS/HoS or other mentions of either.

Under the assumption prof pointed out more than one mafia player in his list, which lead them to kill him.

had MG been on the list (which I could of sworn I remember him being on it) our candidates for a second scum would have been limited to a couple of players if the now know townies ST and Vette been one of his suspects.

Now that MG wasn't on it there's 2 possibilities:

1- Me and J0's theory about 2plus mafias on the proflist still stands and prof's death was indeed because he was threatening.

2- no one on the proflist is scum (something only mafia would know) and this is a dangerous setup by the mafia for us to go after people on the list ... which we are already doing.

You know, if we with # 2, then that lowers the pool for possible mafia a bit. 

If we also take off you and linkz (because linkz has been contributing, and because you just brought this list up again) then we would have 8 players left, with half of them being mafia, 'cause there's possibly four. At that point is thinning it out of innocent looking people until you have a nice number close to four. 

After pulling a stunt like the one in #2, then the mafia would be people trying to lay low. What's the point of trying to cast suspicion on other players and then being suspicious yourself, y'know? 

That would put nen, FF, heph and maybe nord under suspicion. Also because they're so quiet, especially coming from them. 

The only problem with everything I just voted for TruckO. So.... I think there's a chance #1 could be true.