I was in my local best buy today and they had several screens running different high def movies. Batman... Transformers, Open Season, and a couple of others. I noticed something I haven't noticed before... There are times when the scene is "too real" in that it doesn't have the "film look" to it. I would say the comparison is like watching a movie on-screen and watching a soap opera. Soap operas have that "amateur camera" look to them that looks more like you are in the room with them than something that is "on film".
Personally, I've grown so accustomed to the "on film" look that the HD realism kind of ruins it. I guess you get used to it, but I find myself strangely unable to get into the film at all. Does this pass after you've watched enough movie content?