By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 14 - Game Thread

TruckOSaurus said:
  Voting To Lynch ( Lynched | Murdered | Other | Modkilled )
Person Day 1
Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Identity
ArkZero hatmoza
         
Axumblade darthdevidem01
KingFate
       
c03n3nj0 hatmoza
sabby_e17
       
Dgc1808 hatmoza
         
dtewi hatmoza          
Falcon095 darthdevidem01
         
KingFate hatmoza
         
lestatdark hatmoza
         
trashleg
- No Vote - 
         
sabby_e17 darthdevidem01
zexen_lowe        
SciFiBoy hatmoza
         
Seraphic_Sixaxis No Lynch
         
Son1x SciFiBoy          
SuperAdriank  - No Vote -
         
theRepublic No Lynch
         
trangentspree No Lynch
         
Vetteman94 No Lynch
zexen_lowe        
Words of Wisdom  hatmoza          
zexen_lowe hatmoza
sabby_e17        
Seraphic_Sixaxis No Lynch         Mafia Tattaglia Family
darthdevidem01 Falcon095         Vigilante
DaBuddahN hatmoza
        Mafia Roleblocker Corleone Family
dsister44 KingFate
        Jail Keeper
Final-Fan hatmoza
        Townie
nen-suer zexen_lowe
        Mafia Corleone Family
supermario128  sabby_e17         Townie
hatmoza No Lynch
        Townie

If this keeps up I'll be the one with the most kills this round!

another mafia down, yay!

and new family, confirms the multiple mafia thing

also, lol, yeah, come on damned lurkers, PLAY THE GAME



Around the Network

Maybe I am the last to see this but it is now confirmed that there is 2 different mafia factions. Did ToS just update the table or has it always shown this, because I dont remember that.



Oh I see it wasnt an edit it was a new modkill.......



Vetteman94 said:
Maybe I am the last to see this but it is now confirmed that there is 2 different mafia factions. Did ToS just update the table or has it always shown this, because I dont remember that.

new modkill

also of note, 2 "other" kills, so if Darth the vigilante is one, that means there is another one out there somewhere too...



theRepublic said:
My girlfriend got home, I won't be able to post much more tonight. A few quick thoughts:

Falcon didn't FoS or Vote for anyone on Day One. He didn't post at all after page 3 (@100 per page) on Day One. Where are you Falcon?

SuperAdriank didn't FoS or Vote for anyone either. He also didn't post since page 3 (@100 per page) on Day One. I know you are in the hospital, but please try and do something while you are here.

This is a list of people who only Voted for people. They did not FoS anyone. You need to bring your suspects to the attention of the town. Otherwise, you are probably just bandwagoning other people's suspects.

ArkZero
Axumblade
Dgc1808
KingFate
Lestatdark
Seraphic_Sixaxis
Son1x
Trangentspree
Zexen_lowe

I made a whole post saying who I'm suspicious of. Of course, I also mentioned  that I have no opinions on those that haven't posted, like you at the time of my post.



"And yet, I've realized that maybe living a "decent" life means you won't ever have a "good" life."

 

Around the Network

wow, Trucks, you're really good at this game!

the only person who's posts are still jumping out at me is zexen, sabby hasn't really posted much this "day" (that i've noticed) and i've noticed that since the "aggressive" accusations zexen has turned down the volume from about 7 to a 2, lol.

not his usual style at all.
although i do appreciate some of the comments he's made about other folk, but then in a game like this and with so many people its easy to find suspiciousness and "hidden meaning" in any statement really.

and where is sabby?

5:2:1 townsfolk:cornonthecob:tagliatelle

vote:zexen_lowe.



Highwaystar101 said: trashleg said that if I didn't pay back the money she leant me, she would come round and break my legs... That's why people call her trashleg, because she trashes the legs of the people she loan sharks money to.
theRepublic said:
Words Of Wisdom said:
theRepublic said:

These two posts occurred on Day One:

trangentspree said:

In the worst case scenario though we could lose a lot of pro-towns during the night, and if on top of that we've just killed another pro-town, things could get very bad very quickly.

Personally I'm still not convinced a 'no lynch' first night isn't the best way to go about this. Especially now that there have been some interesting moments in the discussion that we can look back on when we find out what happens.

trangentspree said:

Although Hatmoza seems to be making a compelling case to get lynched all by herself, I'm still not a fan lynching someone on a first day when it's based soley on suspicious behaviour or not taking the game seriously enough yet - in my eyes the risk of losing a pro-town isn't worth it when there is always the chance that we could lose a lot of pro-towns during the first night. Maybe it's simply because this is my first game, so I don't know any of your playing styles and can't draw on past experiences to come to conclusions about others like some of you have done, but it just doesn't make sense to me.

However, if the vote against Hatmoza starts to become a majority vote I won't try to drag out this day any longer by opposing it - this day needs to end one way or another so we can get some more concrete facts to look back at this day with. This is just starting to get really confusing now.

So - for the moment - vote: no lynch

Could this be a case of first to say 'X' caused 'X'?  Those statements could make Trangentspree an anti-town night killer.  This makes sense along with the sudden interest in the Doctor.  It does seem a bit too obvious, but he is new, so it might just be a rookie making a big mistake and accidentally revealing himself.

Can you go ahead and explain to me how those make him seem like scum? 

It looks like he's saying the same thing in both place so I'm not making the connection.

I though I made it fairly clear in what I said below the quotes.

Yes, he is saying the same thing in both places.  The connection I am making, is that we did have quite a few deaths during the night excactly like he said.  Could be he is responsible for some of that.  Seems like a big slip up to me, almost too big to be real though (although he is a rookie).  It is enough for some suspicion, but not a vote just yet.  I want to see a response from Trangentspree.

@: I take it what you mean to say is "quite a few pro-town deaths happened during the night just like he said."

@: And qualify "some."

Considering that there were 24 people playing during Day 1, predicting that there could be a lot of fatalities during the first night doesn't seem like a bold claim to me. And anyway, how could I know who was pro-town? The only players that should know the alignment of others during Day 1 are mafia/cult/masons, and they only know the alignments of those inside their own groups.

theRepublic said:
My girlfriend got home, I won't be able to post much more tonight. A few quick thoughts:

Falcon didn't FoS or Vote for anyone on Day One. He didn't post at all after page 3 (@100 per page) on Day One. Where are you Falcon?

SuperAdriank didn't FoS or Vote for anyone either. He also didn't post since page 3 (@100 per page) on Day One. I know you are in the hospital, but please try and do something while you are here.

This is a list of people who only Voted for people. They did not FoS anyone. You need to bring your suspects to the attention of the town. Otherwise, you are probably just bandwagoning other people's suspects.

ArkZero
Axumblade
Dgc1808
KingFate
Lestatdark
Seraphic_Sixaxis
Son1x
Trangentspree
Zexen_lowe

@:This isn't a list of people who "only Voted for people," because I didn't vote for anyone during Day 1 - I voted "No Lynch" as you can clearly even see by looking inside the quotes that you have taken from me.



I've become suspcious of SuperAdrianK...

I know you've been in hospital (hope you're feeling better now buddy ), but it looks like you're hiding behind the comments you make (not really adding to discussion and also saying you're not really sure about the things you have to say). Also you avoided answering my question here after you welcomed being questioned here. I'm also waiting for you to reply to WoW here.

 

I think Falcon, j0 and Son1x are being too wishy-washy in their posts...

Falcon... you're just continually laying into Sabby and j0 - j0 because he is also being wishy-washy. But the only post of substance I can find of yours is this one where you basically just reiterate everything WoW has already said. You've also been abundantly supportive towards WoW, and very defensive about the Hatmoza mislynch (at times even when people aren't using it against anyone).

 

Son1x... so far your only post of substance has been this one (and by your own admission you only made it because, like with j0, WoW directly asked you). You don't seem to have any strong opinions about anyone, but only a couple of posts after this one you're more than ready to jump on me - and so far your only justification for this has been: "He wanted the doctor to roleclaim and I don't like his "bossy" attitude. Plus I'm cool and trust my instincts."

j0, you are the most wishy-washy poster today by far. I literally have nothing to quote you on because nothing you have said so far is substantitive. The only time you gave any opinion about players is when WoW asked you to, and even then your post is pretty much a cop-out. Please link me to post where you've actually made an effort to be helpful towards the town.

 

 

I've been pretty vocal about why I suspect WoW...

and I'm willing to wait on the Cop's report about you (although dtewi can you confirm who it is you're going to investigate tonight?)

 

Zexen...

You've been next to WoW in the people I have been most suspicious of since Day 1. You've also made very little effort to partcipate during Day 2, in both defending yourself against accusations and in trying to help the town by scum-hunting more people. With responses like this and this you've actually managed to become the very thing you lynched Hatmoza for on Day 1 - being generally useless to the town.

 

So this is where I currently stand:

FoS: j0

FoH: WoW

Vote: Zexen



Vote: theRepublic

1) Not using "FoS" doesn't mean anything if you state who you're suspicious of in your posts and why. This was very weak reasoning and I'm thinking you were using it to throw attention away from members of your mafia family that are currently acquiring some votes or something.

2) It was Day 1 in a large game. Someone saying "there's a good chance there's gonna be alot of night kills night 1" doesn't mean squat. I'd expect something like this from someone new to mafia but not you.

3) My initial reason for vote hatmoza was indeed to get the game going. After a whole day of hatmoza posting reply's like "i'm not crazy, it was just a joke" and stating "we should just lynch a lurker and talk" while really adding nothing to the conversation himself- i saw no reason to change my vote.



4 ≈ One

trangentspree said:

and I'm willing to wait on the Cop's report about you (although dtewi can you confirm who it is you're going to investigate tonight?)

This is scummy.

The Cop should never announce who he/she will investigate because it makes that person a prime suspect to be nightkilled.  The same point I made about both the Cop and Mafia targeting me and resulting in a wasted night action goes for any person playing. 

Also, I wouldn't necessarily count on getting an investigation tonight so if you still think I'm guilty tomorrow (and I live) then be prepared to accuse me without one.