By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 14 - Game Thread

@ trangentspree

Yes, I still believe there are 2 mafia left, I've been thinking that for a while now. But I added that (in the second quote), since there's a possibility of me being wrong, but I wasn't fully saying "Oh, it could go either way!" And notice the smiley face.

But you started your argument with this: http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3229107&page=32&postnum=31

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3229006&page=32&postnum=24 and then proposed something with the basis of there being one mafia

And finally, if you really were not sure about there being one or two mafia, then why would you choose to roleclaim, if you didn't think it was more likely of Falcon being the only one?

Or is it that all of a sudden you changed your mind?

I'm tired of quoting, Chrome is being weird. Now me go sleep. School tomorrow.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Around the Network

That's handy, we have the same bedtimes.



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

c03n3nj0 said:
That's handy, we have the same bedtimes.

We are arch-nemesis in every sense of the word. Even slumberland.

Oh god. Even the word slumberland makes me cry for bed right now.

I'll deal with your post tomorrow. Beddybyes.



trangentspree said:
Why isn't dsister talking at all?

There isn't anything for me to add. I've made my position clear and my stance isn't going to change. 

For a quick recap 

  • Falcon is mafia
  • I believe that Zexen is Serial Killer 
  • Out of the two of you I find you the most suspicious.


So let's see..

You killed 3 mafia and practically killed a whole family but didn't do the same with the rest of the players with the exception of darth.
You gave WoW the ability to be immune for 3 nights in a row
You didnt modkilled neither the cop nor the doctor to balance even if both lurked and had problems like modkilled mafias and you EVEN replaced the cop with a player that was ALREADY death WHEN they town had TWO doctors.

Good job, Truck..

The game changed from "the town just screwed themselves" to "the mod just screwed the anti towns"

I wish you good luck, the rest of the anti towns.



||Tag courtesy of fkusumot - "Heaven is like a Nintendo theme park!"||Join the Medal of Honor: Heroes 2 American League HERE!||

Around the Network

Holy crap. I left this game like a month and a half ago and it's still going on?



Falcon095 said:
So let's see..

You killed 3 mafia and practically killed a whole family but didn't do the same with the rest of the players with the exception of darth.
You gave WoW the ability to be immune for 3 nights in a row
You didnt modkilled neither the cop nor the doctor to balance even if both lurked and had problems like modkilled mafias and you EVEN replaced the cop with a player that was ALREADY death WHEN they town had TWO doctors.

Good job, Truck..

The game changed from "the town just screwed themselves" to "the mod just screwed the anti towns"

I wish you good luck, the rest of the anti towns.

Now that you are exposed, care to tell us who your friends are?



PSN ID: KingFate_

Falcon095 said:
So let's see..

You killed 3 mafia and practically killed a whole family but didn't do the same with the rest of the players with the exception of darth.
You gave WoW the ability to be immune for 3 nights in a row
You didnt modkilled neither the cop nor the doctor to balance even if both lurked and had problems like modkilled mafias and you EVEN replaced the cop with a player that was ALREADY death WHEN they town had TWO doctors.

Good job, Truck..

The game changed from "the town just screwed themselves" to "the mod just screwed the anti towns"

I wish you good luck, the rest of the anti towns.

The anti-towns screwed themselves by not participating.



Signature goes here!

Holy FUCK!! This game is still going on!

*Edit: What MM said!



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

@j0

I made the argument that Falcon might be the last mafia, not because I was 100% sure it had to be the case, but because nobody else was making the argument and everyone was assuming otherwise. The point is, I don't know, it's perfectly reasonable to assume either way based on what we know. And I don't think you were looking at it either way - you have just been assuming one over the other.

I roleclaimed because this is the first day the benefits outway the drawbacks for me to do so. I needed to explain my actions across the previous days. If there was a second mafia left, it made it 100% apparent who that mafia was. Amazingly, you decided to make it even more obvious by trying to undermine my roleclaim and with weak accusations, you didn't even state you were the nurse right away and then, when you did claim, you suggested ridiculous things like there might be two nurses but that you didn't think I was the nurse anyway.

If there is no other mafia left and only a SK, as far as I'm aware we don't have any way to detect their role. Knowing who people are in this scenario also benefits the town. With only one scum left, the town could only suffer one further nightkill during the night and there should definitely be a Day7 - even if I attracted the nightkill (and the scum being by himself would only need to target anyone apart from dsister to get an effective nightkill) I would still be able use protection on someone during the night.

As far as I saw things, as soon as dsister announced that Falcon was guilty, there was no reason not to roleclaim, and every advantage to do so. Of course I hadn't predicted that you would be so sneaky as to try undermine my roleclaim in an attempt to confuse the town. Chock that one down to yet another newbie error on my part I guess - you certainly have played well there.